I definitely vote for Hop (Small)! Yes initially I was concerned about the opening after I bought it and feel strange that the opening didn’t feel as small / tight as I tried in the store. Nonetheless, I decided to keep it and started carrying it this week! Absolutely love it. Classy timeless design. Jodie feels abit dated and kiddish for me due to the knot… and feels more causal. Go for the Hop… u won’t regret it