^that's the one I've had for 5 years and it's still in amazing shape!
I've worn the heck out of it because it's the perfect weight for the South.
I'm not kidding, I've totally WORN it, it should be falling apart but I just had it dry cleaned and it's like new again.
The indestructability of it is what convinced me to get another.
If I had to list an issue, i would have to saw the string around the buttons - loose, but that's just a matter of sewing - not a big problem, but other than that - yes, they do hold up nicely!!! I want a Navy blue one, one of these days...