I thought a sure way to spot a Roxanne fake, was to check the D-ring, as I have read that the tab should not be lined, but should be showing in suede, the same as the interior of the bag. These two photos are showing, (in theory) two identical Roxanne's selling on ebay. The first one is new and I am pretty sure is authentic, I have also seen a photo showing the D-ring correctly. The second one is used, and I am having doubts. The seller says it is genuine, but cannot email a photo of the side for some reason, and it looks as though the D-ring is lined as you can see where the leather starts on the inside. Both are identical in colour etc. Could it be a fake? Or do mulberry make them slightly differently each season etc.