Customer Service/Quality Control issues post here.

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Status
Not open for further replies.
Susan Lee, you're one of the sweetest ladies on this forum! I'm SO sorry you had such a negative experience. I'm glad you shared it here though.

I agree with Sgreg though......I think I get annoyed with is NOT the negative issue being discussed, but the 1000 tangents that the thread takes off on that leads to personal attacks.

I've had a few "issues" with BE and yes...they were resolved quickly and professionally. Most recently, one of my bags arrived with a cracked crystal and BE will replace the tag but Jackie wanted me to send it in so the atelier could investigate "why" these cracks are taking place to begin with. I think that's fair.

I've also experienced stitching on the PDA pockets that has come unravelled and had it repaired locally. Now....I did mention this to Jackie and she assured me that these so-called "defects" are rare, but they can happen. If 4 or 5 bags produced experience "issues" among hundreds of bags being handcrafted, I'd said that's a pretty good track record, no?

And the mis-matched hw, well......that's being looked into as well, yes?? Although it should never have happened, Jackie has taken the necessary steps to ensure it will not happen again. That speaks volumes and shows she DOES care about her customers.

Again, I'd like to stress, while this thread is necessary and highly informative, I hope newcomers will try to keep an open mind and form their OWN educated opinion.......as opposed to being coerced or talked out of this brand just because someone has fallen out of love with it.
 
Susan Lee, I think your post was great. I have never had bad experiences (not undermining those who have) but I do have BEC bags on order and I do want to know that if there was a problem, things would get fixed. I don't see any problem with your posts.

Contessa, totally agree with your last comment.
 
Susan Lee..I'm sorry if you think I don't feel with you, and as I understand your difficulties you ordered a bag and due to leather shortage you recieved a completely different bag and not even the same size or what?? This doesn't sound good at all ..and it doesn't sound like BE either.

Contessa: Again, I'd like to stress, while this thread is necessary and highly informative, I hope newcomers will try to keep an open mind and form their OWN educated opinion.......as opposed to being coerced or talked out of this brand just because someone has fallen out of love with it.

I totally agree!!
Also there are sooo many good bags produced by BE and they should not be forgotten! ;)
 
:hugs:Thanks ladies :-) All I can hope for is that this dialogue brings about changes for the better.

:flowers:Contessa, thanks dear. You have always been a wealth of knowledge and right back atcha with the sweet comment :-)

Aww Bonnie I honestly dont think that at all.:smile1: You have always been kind and friendly and I am really glad when people have great experiences! This forum is such a great tool, yet it is always so difficult to get across true feeling and "tone" in posts, kwim? And I am still jealous of your hold me rainbow!

In the end, my BEC problem is done with, and hopefully wont happen to anyone else in the future. I want this company to do WELL! Nobody is perfect and along with the good comes the bad sometimes-one must hear all sides before one can improve or change.
 
Oh no, Susan Lee, what did they do to your bag due to the leather shortage? Did they change it to a midi? You certainly should have been consulted about something that occurred due to a leather shortage.
 
Oh no, nothing like that sgreg! I ordered a BEC bag made from limited leather stock, and some extras that I had requested/ ordered were not included on my bag by the atelier supposedly because they had run out of the leather. I was not notified of the leather shortage until I received my bag and emailed about the "mistake" or "unauthorized change" made on my bag, nor was I ever asked if this change was ok prior to doing so.
 
Last edited:
Oh no, nothing like that sgreg! I ordered a BEC bag made from limited leather stock, and some extras that I had requested/ ordered were not included on my bag by the atelier supposedly because they had run out of the leather. I was not notified of the leather shortage until I received my bag and emailed about the "mistake" or "unauthorized change" made on my bag, nor was I ever asked if this change was ok prior to doing so.

Ah! I would have been unhappy, had that happened to me. The atelier should have realized this before they started cutting your bag, and you should have been consulted and presented with alternatives/given a chance to change or cancel your order.

(On the positive side, I think I may be the very happy beneficiary of this issue...I have what I'm presuming is your pearlised brown LM midi! <3)
 
I am an attorney and known to be blunt, so excuse if this offends.



Frankly, I think this thread should be closed. Jackie does herself a disservice by threads like this imo. The bags speak for themselves. I have purchased the highest priced bes on the board and have about 17 or so non-exotic others. I haven't had any major issues and the quality of the bags I have been getting speak for themselves.



I dont always agree with everything BE does and will call out things I dislike (moneybookers, prior poor packaging -which has improved YAY!, etc. ), but I continue to purchase the bags because the quality is good and I find they are a value for what you get.



People will post complaints-- it is the nature of the Internet. I know it is hard for her to not take it personally, but it is just business. All manufacturers have issues. JC royally messed up a one-off custom croc bag for me. I would let people post what they will on the cs thread and ignore it. Again, the bags speak for themselves. For every bad comment there are 14 positive ones.



From reading these threads it is clear that there are be cheerleaders and be haters. Can't we all just get along? If you like the bags keep posting the positive reviews. If you have issues, post your concern ONCE, provide an update but then move on.



Since it was raised before, I am the poster with the issues with Ignes CS. I was their biggest customer on tpf and purchased over 30? bags from them. It got to the point where 7 orders in a row had major issues. I received rotting bags made out of stinky rotting fish that were not wearable, wrong orders, leathers changed without explanation, crooked zippers, broken handles, mis-matched sealants, leather paint peeling off, seams missing paint, etc. I always had to send pictures and responsibility was not always taken by them and it ended up just being excuse after excuse. NOT every bags was replaced or refunded by them. I quit purchasing the brand, posted my issue and then moved on and quit posting in that subforum. If you have nothing but problems with Be, post your issue, update if a resolution is reached or not but move on.



I am by no means a be cheerleader and consider myself pretty neutral but the constant drama in this subforum is a big turn off. It is the holidays people-- lets lighten up and agree to disagree. Everyone can post what they want, but lets not beat it into the ground.



Happy pre-turkey day to everyone!



As Contessa so succinctly said, these are handbags folks! Thanks to Jackie for starting this thread, but IMO, it has veered totally away from what I perceive her intent to have been. I've ordered quite a few BE's including two bespokes (pre BEC) and two BEC -- all have showed up perfectly as ordered - I will say that I am very clear with directions and always take the time to follow up and confirm. I did have an issue on one of the sales - I bought a bag that turned up missing -- Jackie quickly took care of the issue and I was very happy with the result!



I did try to read through this thread, but some of the posts were just too long and my eyes glazed -- I did go check the zipper on my MMS and yes, it is wavy - never noticed it before, it works perfectly, it doesn't look funny at all when it's carried - the leather "sides" cover it anyway and I also checked another long zipper I have on another similarly priced handbag line and it is wavy as well so I do believe that is the nature of long zippers just as an fyi.


Karmen - to answer your question - anyone is welcome to post about their issues on this forum and TPF in general -- just in the correct thread and from what I managed to read on this thread, the feeling was that this was not the correct thread to discuss that particular situation.



Although the discussion began on the other thread due to a specific reason, I don't want to beat a dead horse. In fact, regardless of what the intent was, I agree that the other BE QC thread started by Jackie should be closed so that BE will post on the appropriate threads and customers will post CS/QC issues on appropriate threads. Some things should be discussed on the BE website. Others, on twitter or facebook if needed.

But please understand, until it is resolved, it will not go away nor will I.

Suzeee, When a thread annoys me, I stop reading it and move on.

If you personally are happy with wavy, poorly set in zippers, that is your choice as a customer. I am not happy with them, that is my choice. I do not own a single non-BE purse regardless of pricepoint that has zippers set in, in this "wavy", crooked manner. Any seamstress or tailor or leather craftsman worth his or her salt knows how to set in zippers properly. As I said, I sew and have worked in the business. If it was a leather dress, or skirt with a longer zipper and it was set in in this manner, would it be acceptable?

With my MMS, it wasn't a matter only of cosmetics but a matter of function. It was difficult to open and close. There is a lot more that I could say but I prefer to keep quiet. Furthermore, once again, this is off the topic. THAT matter was resolved. Let's drop it once and for all. I expressed this earlier

Suzzeee, I don't want to say anything else about any other brand, since you and I share space in other forums, other to say that I post about QC/CS and other issues on other forums, as do you. You are entitled to your opinion and I am entitled to mine. I respect you, please do the same for me.

LL, I don't want to discuss Ignes here but I do agree with you on this point. You did what you chose to do, I will do what I choose to do about a brand. I agree with your choice and why you felt you had to do what you did. I respect that. I personally don't hate BE, it's a company. All companies have pluses and minuses. Simply put, I just want to return the bag and be done with it.

FWIW, since you are an attorney, you will understand why I am posting what follows in the manner in which I am. There is communication of a particular intent, tone and nature regarding this purchase in particular and me as a customer as well, that you are not aware of and of which I do not want to disclose any specific details, but it did have a proposed resolution and not in a manner that I was comfortable with. It is private and between BE and me.

I do not want to violate any rules or laws by saying anything more other than to express that this correspondance is a CS issue not a QC issue.

Regarding this final BE purchase of mine, the issue was brought up here, issue will be resolved and the resolution posted here, the matter as well as the discussion will be closed, I will move on and away from the brand as you have moved away from that one. That too is another statement you made that I too will concede is true.

As for the rest, thank you for voicing your opinion. An open forum is a wonderful place to discuss QC and CS issues among customers and share experiences both positive and negative. That is how customers can also do their own due diligence and read both the positive and the negative and make an informed choice of whether or not to purchase anything.

Now, as far as closing the other CS thread, since the heading was "Quality Issues at BE" regardless of the intent of the OP, if that is what is going to happen, so be it. Not beating it to the ground, BTW. BE opened it, posted on it, I responded on it and whether or not it was BE's intent for this to be aired here, I already explained why I posted there and not on the THIS thread.

Finally, I'm tired of having to justify myself as a customer who purchased a stock item that is not final sale, where no photo was posted, that was described as excellent, and am unhappy with it because of the way it was made, and merely wants to return it.

Happy Thanksgiving to all.
 
GB - for the record, the zipper on my MMS is not poorly set in at all - it's fine - the zipper part is merely wavy when it's in a relaxed state - it's not actually crooked. Furthermore, I said absolutely nothing at all about your opinion or anyone else's for that matter -- I merely stated that when I heard this about the zippers, I went to check mine - I was curious! I then reported my finding in my post. I thought perhaps my observation would be helpful to someone looking to purchase that particular style.

I'm a huge fan of BE and have never made any secret of that -- I think Jackie is extremely talented, BE is a high quality product and I'd like very much for her company to succeed because she deserves to! I said absolutely nothing negative about you, your bags, your opinion - nothing whatsoever in my post. I cannot for the life of me see how you could possibly construe that I, in any way was attempting to prevent you from voicing your opinion and if you did get that feeling, I am very sorry that you took it that way - it was intended to be exactly what it was -- my personal thoughts and experience with regards to BE's quality/CS. Hey - I'm a big proponent of free speech as long as it's not doing irreparable harm to anyone and frankly, I cannot imagine how a conversation about handbags could possibly do that.

I will also freely admit, I'm much more a fan of shorter posts with paragraphs- much easier to read after a glass of wine, but hey - that's just my preference - not making any judgment here - just stating my feelings about the subject.

....slinking off to the Gucci forum now.....
 
suzzeee, I did get your original intention, but I, at the same time, see why GB understood you post as she did. It can seem like you were trying to say that the zipper that GB got indeed had no problem and that it is the nature of the MMS zipper. I think this is simple misunderstanding. no offense to anyone.
 
Maybe the reason there seems to be more of a mix of happy and unhappy or undecided customers here is because this is a new brand and the jury is still out for some of those who have been disappointed by troubled transactions but still like that bags and, therefore, are on the fence about BE.

In any case, there's no question that a customer is within her rights to raise objections if a bag did not meet expectations set by the seller, particularly if it's defective like the MMS with a crooked zipper. Opinions and experiences, whether on the positive or negative side, are precisely what these forums are about--right?

Something I find a bit alarming, however, is the possibility that a bag maker would censor what a customer can or cannot post here about a bag or transaction. IMO, whether we're dealing with a long-established brand like Chanel or a new player like BE, it shouldn't matter: a customer should be able to share her experience with the company--positive, neutral or negative--without fear of some sort of retribution because of a pending return/refund.

I'm not claiming that this is taking place or not or how...as I'm not in a position to know the details. I'm only making an observation based on several posts on this and other threads.

To you GB and any others with pending resolutions: I wish you good luck. I truly hope the issues will be resolved fairly and to your satisfaction.

flowerysmile.gif
 

Something I find a bit alarming, however, is the possibility that a bag maker would censor what a customer can or cannot post here about a bag or transaction. IMO, whether we're dealing with a long-established brand like Chanel or a new player like BE, it shouldn't matter: a customer should be able to share her experience with the company--positive, neutral or negative--without fear of some sort of retribution because of a pending return/refund.

If I recall correctly, BE's response to this issue in an older post was that they were happy for us to post the issue at hand, pics, whatever, and the general gist of the exchanges. They'd prefer if we didn't post the emails directly, or post the specific resolution except to say that it was resolved/not resolved and whether the customer was satisfied.

Their reason was something like they'd had instances where a customer had their heart set on the same resolution as another tfp member, when the QC case was different and warranted a different solution. BE claimed that it put them in a difficult situation, and the poster/s in the instances claimed BE was showing some people preferential treatment. etc, etc, and hence the request to not spell out the detail here.

I have no idea whether this is what happens in practice or not, but that was the gist of the explanation as far as I understood it.
 
If I recall correctly, BE's response to this issue in an older post was that they were happy for us to post the issue at hand, pics, whatever, and the general gist of the exchanges. They'd prefer if we didn't post the emails directly, or post the specific resolution except to say that it was resolved/not resolved and whether the customer was satisfied.

Their reason was something like they'd had instances where a customer had their heart set on the same resolution as another tfp member, when the QC case was different and warranted a different solution. BE claimed that it put them in a difficult situation, and the poster/s in the instances claimed BE was showing some people preferential treatment. etc, etc, and hence the request to not spell out the detail here.

I have no idea whether this is what happens in practice or not, but that was the gist of the explanation as far as I understood it.

Correct.

Karmen..The 2-3 minor incidents I have had with BE....I got these resolved in a manner that made me blush..and I'm not an easy person to deal with in general :D...don't mess with my principals or my money!
 
Last edited:
Oh no, nothing like that sgreg! I ordered a BEC bag made from limited leather stock, and some extras that I had requested/ ordered were not included on my bag by the atelier supposedly because they had run out of the leather. I was not notified of the leather shortage until I received my bag and emailed about the "mistake" or "unauthorized change" made on my bag, nor was I ever asked if this change was ok prior to doing so.

This sounds very cryptic..was it longer handles?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top