I tried both, and I didn't like how either looked. Don't quite know what I'm going to do with this bag. I scrubbed off both products, with leather CPR before they dried into permanence. I pulled out the inner flap and looked at the original leather color on the back of the edges there, so pretty. So pristine! Ah, the ravages of time... ETA: I think some part of the product is still there, because it does look better than before. But not all cakey and weird like it did when I applied it. Maybe I've invented a new technique. Put it on, scrape it off, and then you have a light application.
I learned this the hard way but now I usually avoid badly worn and/or stained light-colored bags. If you don't think that you will feel comfortable carrying your bag in it's current condition then you might consider dying it a darker color.
I have never tried to dye a bag myself but there are other rehabbers on this forum that have done it themselves successfully, so they may be able to advise you. You may be able to have it dyed black by a professional later, if you aren't successful at doing it yourself.
If you do decide to dye the bag, wash it again well to remove the conditioner and other products, because the conditioner can interfere with getting a nice, even color from the dye.
I once (way back in 2011!) had a large, light-colored bag dyed professionally. It was a putty Light Tote 4065 (from around 1990) and it was part of the Lightweights Line. It was a great bag but it had been treated roughly and it was badly soiled and worn - and it had a big stain on the front near the bottom. I rehabbed it and it looked a lot better but it still wasn't great, and that big stain wouldn't budge.
I finally took it to a shoe repair shop and had it dyed black. It looked much better after it was dyed but I was still a little disappointed. The black color was bright and shiny outside (but I missed that vintage patina!) and it still looked terrible on the inside! I guess I assumed that the cobbler would also dye the inside suede leather but he didn't - and it still looked old and soiled inside and that big stain was still visible on the inside.
If I ever decide to have another all-leather bag dyed I will tell them to try and not make it so shiny and new-looking, and that I also want them to dye the inside!
You can see the before and after pics of my poor, Putty Light Tote 4065 at the link below:
In September I bought a "Made in the United States" large putty tote at the Savers Thrift Store for $13. Hyacinth authenticated it and told me that "It's called a Light Tote, style 4065 from the Lightweights line, probably right around 1990 give or take a year. It has an industrial-style...
forum.purseblog.com