I wonder if the toothpaste bleached out the color. Did you use a whitening toothpaste?Quoting my own post to update you all on the Chester saga: 28 hours into drying, after a second coat of CPR, the toothpaste reared its ugly head again, albeit to a lesser degree. True to my word, I chucked her in the washing machine. Please cross as many fingers and toes as you can spare.