No, they don't have the same kind of leather. The new Willis, the duffles, and the Legacy bucket all have different types of leather. My Legacy Willis has very shiny smooth leather. I think some of the new Willises had waxed leather. The duffles have semi-smooth leather with dye that doesn't go all the way through. When the corners start showing white, I haven't found a way to fix them. The normal things I do for faded corners don't work on them. The Legacy bucket has wonderful, thick leather that holds up wonderfully. I think the two bags you are talking about probably have leather similar to the duffles. The leather isn't particularly delicate so you should be able to clean them.Definitely helpful for me, thanks! Do you know if these carabiner rings came in a gold/brass looking finish? The link to them on amazon did not work for me.
I called Coach the other day and they said the Coach moisturizer only not the cleaner can be used on this bag. I have one too that's tan/brass and no stripe lining. I tried the moisturizer and it possibly helped it's hard to tell.
Another question for all you rehabbers:
Do all the 2012 legacy line items have the same type of leather that can't be cleaned? I'm wondering specifically about the turnlock mini saddle bag and legacy leather Penny bags.
I got carbiner rings like that in brass on ebay.