Oh, your bag is beautiful! Thank you for the tips. I think I will try a coat of CPR before dunking. I also read this online:
"Alas, some of his clients haven't stopped there. In his Bothell repair shop, Boutcher displays a badly cracked and split armrest - victim of a general-purpose household cleaner. But Boutcher says the absolute worst product to use on leather is saddle soap because it's too alkaline, and will cause the leather to dry out and eventually crack. Alkalinity, in fact, is the problem with all soaps because leather has an acid pH. To keep leather conditioned, the leather pros recommend only one product. Called Lexol, it's found in many shoe repair shops and has the correct pH."
This is from an article in the Seattle Times where they interviewed the owners of European Leather Repair. They are supposed to know there stuff, even did repairs for the German Leather Museum. What do you think?
In general I agree. I won't ever use saddle soap. Lexol is what I use to just wipe down my bags from time to time, but it isn't strong enough to remove set in dirt and stains, unfortunately. I tend to use Woolite for most of my rehabs. The ones that are horribly dirty- and therefore Id have "nothing to lose" by being aggressive, I'll try Dawn, or Tide, or Oxi Clean and try to rinse it really really well. But I worry that the long term effects of aggressive cleaning won't be good. However, somewhere waaaay back in this thread, one of the gals posted an old bit of info published by Coach, talking about how the older glove tanned Coach bags were actually designed to withstand being dunked in water and cleaned that way. Maybe Coach eventually wanted new business, so quit announcing that little fact to the world, who knows. As far as the tears in the leather, I wonder if a cobbler could put a little bit of a leather patch in there, or maybe even a leather safe fabric glue could reinforce it and strengthen it from further harm. Others may have more thoughts on this.