Im probably going to be in the minority here, but I dont care for LV bags at all. First of all, if Im going to spend that much on a bag, it better be leather. Second, there are SOOOO many knock-off LVs around here (and Coach signature in khaki/tan - another reason I dont do signature) that if I saw your bag, I would just assume it was a knock-off. Now thats really none of my business, lol, and you arent carrying the bag for what I think of it, but thats what I would think. Also, I just dont care for many of the LV prints/patterns, etc. Do you have pictures of each bag so we can see them side by side? I know I would still pick the Coach, tho. Good luck with your decision!