Do not risk it, the bag can be confiscated. You need existing CITES to enter the U.S.Question for anyone who has ever traveled with an exotic from Brazil to the U.S.--did this require a CITES? It's an alligator bag I am interested in purchasing secondhand and bringing back to the U.S., but it does not have a CITES. Based on what I have read about the laws (under chapter 4, exception III, here: https://faolex.fao.org/docs/pdf/bra112515.pdf), CITES is not required for personal items. For my peace of mind, I wondered if anyone can confirm CITES is not needed for this. Thank you so much.
As for Brazil, I have emailed them before, and they told me to get in and out of the country you need CITES and the invoice. You do not need to reapply for a new CITES because they accept personal exemption, but you need the CITES.