Hi BigAkoya
Thanks so much for sharing so much detail on your sizing experience with the loafers. I'm in the exact same boat i.e. same dilemna between 38 vs 38.5. I currently have a size 38 and have worn it a handful of times and have been questioning whether i bought too small of a size. Length fits perfectly though. How long did it take for them to break and feel comfortable from a width perspective ?
I've been wanting to get a size 38.5 so the width doesn't feel too tight...but i know the length is going to be an issue. Now i'm questioning my decision based on what you've shared, so really appreciate that. Thank you
Hi!
I have two pairs now (fucshia and black), and I have been wearing them often. I love love love this style and would like to get another color.
I will say they are definitely comfy! I could not say that though when I first got them. They were not comfy at all, and I thought ugh... these shoes are not for me.
I got the fucshia pair first. Had my first pair been the black, I would have returned them (not really into black shoes), but because the fucshia was so hard to find, I decided to tough it out. I wanted to see if they would fit better after I wore it a few times or if would be another "waste of money" shoe.

I am so so glad I kept them as now, I can walk miles in them. Here's what I experienced and did...
The 38 out of the box was not comfy at all, even walking around in my closet. They were super snug around the widest part of my foot. The shoe is also very stiff, and I usually do not buy stiff shoes, so it also annoyed me the shoe was a bit hard to slip on at first. I felt like I had duck feet trying to slip into feminine ballets flats.

What to do? Hmmm...
I had this idea to wear thick socks around the house first to stretch them a bit, and yes, they did stretch a bit.
I wore them out for the first time, and ugh... they were still narrow at the widest part of my foot and hurt my bone (the bone under the toe). I think I have a tiny bunion as that bone is super sensitive. I went out for lunch and walking from the parking lot to the restaurant made that that bone hurt. I thought... double ugh... this was a wasted experiment.
My husband says he likes that bright fuchsia, so okay... I am not giving up!
I wore them for short periods I think about 5-7 times, and one day, they feel great! They are even on the loose side a bit...I love them!
So... be patient and wear them for short outings several times. They will stretch a bit for sure as they did for me.
I wear them really casual... with a chunky sweater and loose jeans with the hem rolled up. It's fall here on the US east coast, and the weather is getting cool. I purchased some fun socks to wear with them. My jean hem is rolled up (or cropped flare) so the socks can peek out from my jeans.
If you like this look, maybe try wearing them with fun socks for a few times too.
Hope this helps.