Both jackets are great on you so it depends if you want a LBJ or a tweed one. The second one has a more casual vibe to it. The Sofia is not an easy fit on everyone and you pull it off. The shoulders do not appear big in the photos but you can always have the boutique switch them to the smaller padding.
Finally tried this jacket (not in my size) but alas the metallic threads itches me badly especially at the back of the neck (even over my dress). Much as I like the look, it is a pass. Seems like it will be Hermes rtw for me this season.
View attachment 3791875
Both look wonderful on you as always!
ms piggy, thank you [emoji4]
The jacket looks good with this dress!