can't keep 'em all...

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#16
I would return the tote, but I'm totally biased toward the legacy line in general. I can tell you love the Mandy (and while it might not be a deal, it certainly might be used enough by you to justify the price) and I'm a total shoulder bag slut - I have 2 of them and want another in pond, so I just can't tell you to sell the shoulder bag. I don't think the signature stripe is as practical/versatile as the legacy stuff, IMO.
 
#17
Bags4Bubbles said:
I would say if you feel like you need to take one of them back - take back the punch tote, its cute, but you can get the accesories (or you might already have them?) to fill your urge there.

The leather bags are bound to last longer for style & for the amount of abuse they can take. They will also transition well from one area of life to another...

An alternate argument may be, if you feel like you've over-extended yourself, take back the Mandy. While it is fantastic, you can get the same effect out of a messenger bag for right now and splurge on the bigger leather bag later on....
Click to expand...

Bags4, said it everything that I would recommend. From a personal perspective, I think that the shoulder it a great bag.
 
#18
Kallison,
I don't think you can purchase the Mandy or shoulder bag in whiskey right now. they are long gone. So I would sell the shoulder bag and then debate about the tote. if you return the mandy, you may not be able to replace it, unless you buy it in the natural at the next pce. which is a good idea if you like the natural as well as the whiskey.
 
#20
I would return the tote because the Legacy line is limited and just beautiful IMO!:love:I think both the Mandy and Shoulder Bag are very classy and timeless!:yes:
 
#22
lovecoach said:
Kallison,
I don't think you can purchase the Mandy or shoulder bag in whiskey right now. they are long gone. So I would sell the shoulder bag and then debate about the tote. if you return the mandy, you may not be able to replace it, unless you buy it in the natural at the next pce. which is a good idea if you like the natural as well as the whiskey.
Click to expand...

Actually, you can still buy the mandy in whiskey. :yes: On coach.com they are still selling it, and some of the stores still have them as well. However, I'm sure it's limited though. It's the shoulder bag in whiskey that they are not selling on the website anymore and it's basically just about sold out now.

willowsmom - OMG you made me laugh!! :roflmfao: :roflmfao: "total shoulder bag slut" I'd have to say, I'm the same way and totally biased towards the shoulder bag too. So Kallison, if you really love the mandy, then keep it. Because that completely justifies the price. :yes:
 
#24
I probably wouldn't keep both Legacy bags because they are so similar. I fell for the Mandy first, but it was so heavy and so expensive that I ended up with the shoulder bag. And with the back pain studies now (linked to heavy bags), maybe the shoulder is better. It's heavy enough in my opinion.

I love the tote in punch, but I'd say either keep the shoulder and the punch or just keep the Mandy...but not all three.
 
#25
I say keep the bag also you love because it is better to have one you really love and use than a some others that just sit in their dust bag. I have the same problem also and want all of them but I try to be pratical and end up with little stuff I will not use so sometimes it is best to go with the one than several.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top