I have one from Rebecca minkoff which has multiple compartments and an ID window as well. I think it is called Molly metro card case.
Here is a blogpost, I have exactly the same one:
http://www.thetsarina.com/2013/11/rebecca-minkoff-molly-metro-holder.html
This piece is great, got completed drenched with me one time when I was tubing on a small river
The saffiano still holds up. The only issue I had is sometimes it bulges up with too many keys inside it, then it is not a good fit for some of my bags. Then I found this Diesel 6 key holder to replace that.
The leather is surprisingly good for a fashion brand that is not specialized in leather goods. It has three slip pocket so it holds a couple of cards and cash. I love the design for the car key, as I need the actual key to start my car. This would be a great design for valet parking as well.
I have been looking for 6 key holders with slip pockets from premier designers but very few of them have the car key design. LV has a car key pouch but the car key is actually attached by a waxed string...how could that possibly hold up?