CORRECTION TO MY ORIGINAL POST:
Speaking ONLY of the tote you bought a few years ago:
Along with the problems BeenBurned mentioned I'm concerned about the plant code M and also about the year code which should be "04" with a zero, not with the letter"O" and that's not the sort of mistake that should have been made. I'm also seeing what could be sloppy and uneven stitching on the leather straps and trim.
Here's a photo of the creed patch from one of the replica-selling sites - the creed is absolutely identical to the one in your bag. There's very little doubt in my mind that yours is fake, and probably from the same supplier or maker. The only difference is that the creed thread is thicker on yours.