AUTHENTICATE This COACH

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Status
Not open for further replies.
Originally Posted by BeenBurned Originally Posted by cleanclear2007 http://static.purseblog.com/tpf/buttons/viewpost.gif Item: VINTAGE CLASSIC COACH Womens Leather Satchel Purse 4922
Listing number: 330604419150
Seller: relytinc
Link: Images - http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-CLAS...item4cf98f184e


Comments:

I have never seen this vintage coach sold by anyone else, although the leather and trim both look like high quality, can anyone help me identify its authenticity? Thank you very much in advance



Originally Posted by Hyacinth http://static.purseblog.com/tpf/buttons/viewpost.gif It looks fine, although the removeable long shoulder strap seems to be missing. It's a Sonoma Satchel Natural Grain although it looks like the factory made a mistake when stamping the serial number - the style should be 4921 instead of the 4922 that they stamped. That could be one of the reasons the bag has the "FS" (final sale) stamp on the creed. I can't read the creed to see the year (you may want to ask for a better creed photo) but it's from the mid-1990s.




Good catch re possible shill bidding. If you're interested in this seller's items, keep an eye on the bidding.

There's a possibility that it could be a legitimate buyer looking for a deal. She's bidding on the 99-cent Coach listings only. But it's odd that she's not bidding on any of the many other sellers' items with low starting prices.

Personally, I'd feel uncomfortable enough that I probably wouldn't bid but if the price stays reasonable and you really want the bag, you'd have to make that call yourself.

The creed pic on the white bag looks crooked...maybe it's just my eyes can anyone confirm? The creed does read 4922 on the white one as well and I don't see a FS stamp???

The creed stamps on the Sonomas WERE sloppy. And the Italians have always had a very carefree attitude about following production rules or diagrams and "reading the memos" about things like using the correct style or month codes. Take it from someone who's sold and/or owned Italian cars, following wiring diagrams isn't something they do well either. Anyone who's ever owned or driven a FIAT, Alfa or Maserati will understand what I'm talking about.

There's nothing wrong with that bag other than a few human mistakes. The possible shill bidding is a bigger problem that the funky creeds.
 
Originally Posted by BeenBurned Originally Posted by cleanclear2007 http://static.purseblog.com/tpf/buttons/viewpost.gif Item: VINTAGE CLASSIC COACH Womens Leather Satchel Purse 4922
Listing number: 330604419150
Seller: relytinc
Link: Images - http://www.ebay.com/itm/VINTAGE-CLAS...item4cf98f184e


Comments:

I have never seen this vintage coach sold by anyone else, although the leather and trim both look like high quality, can anyone help me identify its authenticity? Thank you very much in advance



Originally Posted by Hyacinth http://static.purseblog.com/tpf/buttons/viewpost.gif It looks fine, although the removeable long shoulder strap seems to be missing. It's a Sonoma Satchel Natural Grain although it looks like the factory made a mistake when stamping the serial number - the style should be 4921 instead of the 4922 that they stamped. That could be one of the reasons the bag has the "FS" (final sale) stamp on the creed. I can't read the creed to see the year (you may want to ask for a better creed photo) but it's from the mid-1990s.




Good catch re possible shill bidding. If you're interested in this seller's items, keep an eye on the bidding.

There's a possibility that it could be a legitimate buyer looking for a deal. She's bidding on the 99-cent Coach listings only. But it's odd that she's not bidding on any of the many other sellers' items with low starting prices.

Personally, I'd feel uncomfortable enough that I probably wouldn't bid but if the price stays reasonable and you really want the bag, you'd have to make that call yourself.



The creed stamps on the Sonomas WERE sloppy. And the Italians have always had a very carefree attitude about following production rules or diagrams and "reading the memos" about things like using the correct style or month codes. Take it from someone who's sold and/or owned Italian cars, following wiring diagrams isn't something they do well either. Anyone who's ever owned or driven a FIAT, Alfa or Maserati will understand what I'm talking about.

There's nothing wrong with that bag other than a few human mistakes. The possible shill bidding is a bigger problem that the funky creeds.


Thank you! :D
 
Item: Madison satchel
Listing number: 170669237805
Seller:
energyambit
Link: http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-COA...805?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item27bcade62d

Comments: ?Real and worth $210?
Welcome to tPF.

If you go to the top right of the page and search energyambit's ID, you'll find multiple posts where the seller has been found to have listed fakes. I wouldn't recommend a seller who mixes fakes in with authentic items.

http://forum.purseblog.com/search.php?searchid=20892470

Here's one of the posts that refer to at least 2 listings for fakes: http://forum.purseblog.com/coach-shopping/authenticate-this-coach-694619-6.html#post19486994
 
Yikes! Thank you.

I haven't seen anything posted about this seller. Is this bag legit?

Item:Vintage Coach Helen's Legacy Bucket Bag
Listing number: 250880128895
Seller: jude309

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Coa...895?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item3a699ef77f



Welcome to tPF.

If you go to the top right of the page and search energyambit's ID, you'll find multiple posts where the seller has been found to have listed fakes. I wouldn't recommend a seller who mixes fakes in with authentic items.

http://forum.purseblog.com/search.php?searchid=20892470

Here's one of the posts that refer to at least 2 listings for fakes: http://forum.purseblog.com/coach-shopping/authenticate-this-coach-694619-6.html#post19486994
 
Anyone know the model name and year this bag was produced?

The style is called a Beekman Brief style 5266. The year is confusing me a bit though. The earliest one I can find in the catalogs in 1991, but the inside zipper seems like it should belong to an earlier style, and the format of the serial number wasn't used after 1990. So my best guess would be maybe a very early production model around 1990.

Hopefully NoShoePolish will stop by and take a look.
 
Yikes! Thank you.

I haven't seen anything posted about this seller. Is this bag legit?

Item:Vintage Coach Helen's Legacy Bucket Bag
Listing number: 250880128895
Seller: jude309

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Vintage-Coa...895?pt=US_CSA_WH_Handbags&hash=item3a699ef77f


I would not recommend buying from JUDE309 - the seller currently has a fake listed with an invalid serial number "M7904". Anyone who sells Coach on a regular basis as she seems to should have recognised that it wasn't a genuine Coach number. The bag you asked about seems to be genuine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top