LOL, I'm surprised you didn't walk up to her and tell her how tacky you thought her bag was. Guess you waited for TPF to do that.
I'll never undersand these threads. Why does anyone need to hear from others that dislike a particular line? What's the purpose of it other than to bash it? IMO, if you don't like a particular line, don't buy it. Pretty simple logic. But if someone does have a line that you dislike, respect it and leave it alone.
This happened alot with the mirror line. Funny thing was there was a thread bashing it pretty badly and the OP wound up CHANGING HER MIND and getting a mirror bag.