K, you continue to be the yin to my yang.

I would feel so overwhelmed with a stack like that. I just can’t do lots of random stuff on my arms. One bracelet, no watch and I’m good to go!
And, diamonds don’t look dated but, settings and styles can.
I had two yellow gold rings that were at least 15 years old. The style of the bands were really chunky mainly because gold was cheaper then so, they looked dated compared to more delicate current styles. Or the Return to Tiffany’s jewelry. It was really in say 15 years ago-ish. Now, it’s not so much. I kept my yg versions because I love them but, they certainly aren’t “hot” items right now. And pear or marquis shaped diamond engagement stones were hugely popular 25 years ago. Then they were totally “out” and now they are coming back in vogue. Antique settings for engagement rings were huge 12ish years ago. Now, they aren’t the craze but, you can’t swing a dead cat without seeing halo rings.
Jewelry is like any other fashion. It comes in, gets run out on a rail, swoops back around and is rediscovered all over again. But, it’s so expensive and it’s so personal that I think people should buy what they love and pretty much ignore a trend change.
P.S. I don’t think you’d look cheap in diamonds. Come on over to the sparkly side.

LOL!!! <said in my best Darth Vader voice>