What works for me is knowing my exact measurements for rise, inseam, and waist. I know Everlane provides these measurements, and I really think all honest retailers should! I never go by size anymore, but by measurements. This is all a learning experience from returning SO many ill-fitting jeans over the span of a couple of years. Black jeans tend to be tighter because of the kind of dye and material needed to get a true black!![]()
Dye matters, as does the way denim is stacked before it’s cut. Many (too many to count!) years ago, I had a summer job in a store that sold a lot of jeans — brands like Lee and Levi. The manager told me the reason two pairs of jeans in the same size will fit differently is that denim is stacked and then machine cuts straight down through the stack. The result is that jeans from the denim at the top of the stack will be a little smaller than the denim at the bottom. I don’t know if it’s true but it makes sense for mass-produced clothing.