I know its a sample sale piece, but I think its ridiculous that they are making you pay to get it repaired. I know Botkier is supposed to have great quality, but the only piece I own I had probelms with...my Clyde (pale gold) had a small part where the leather stretched and revealed the white underneath. I got it for practically nothing at a boutique so I just kept it- since the color is so light and meatllic, you cant really notice anyways. I have always been cautious to buy another Botkier and this is definitely making me steer clear. I hope everything works out and I hope they dont charge you much!