I agree with Tanukiki, they are two totally different bags. The Carly to me is more slouchy and casual, while the shopper is more structured and formal. That said, I would still use either as an every day bag. I have a Carly and love it very much, and I do also like the shopper as long as it would fit over my shoulder - I havent seen it in real life yet, but it looks like a beautiful bag. You really cant go wrong either way. As someone said, go and try them on and see how they feel.