Leah, can you tell us why it would get scratched easily around the H closure? I haven't used mine yet, but trying to get in and out was so tough! I'm afraid I will break the closure...
Arlv8500, you know that part where you have to put a bit of pressure with your finger/fingernail to open the H clasp, right under the middle of the H part?
I find that no matter how gently you try to pry it open, the leather part in that area will eventually get a bit scratched. I have a few Constance bags in box leather and that part near the closure always has a little bit of scuffing from trying to pry it open.
The weird thing in my case is that the exotic Constances are the easiest to pry open, meaning with very little pressure, the bag will open. So strangely with exotic Constances, there are virtually no scratches near the clasp area.
It's a bit tougher to open the box Constances - not sure if this is just in my particular case!