I agree with this. The point of the thread was to speculate on why people buy fakes, but somehow it turned into people defending buying fakes, or saying it's okay to buy counterfeits. Now, I don't think people who buy fakes are horrible people, but I certainly don't agree with buying counterfeits in any way.
Why Do People Buy Fake Designer Bags Or Fake Designer Anything?
- Thread starter uber-chic
- Start date
TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others
I agree with this. The point of the thread was to speculate on why people buy fakes, but somehow it turned into people defending buying fakes, or saying it's okay to buy counterfeits. Now, I don't think people who buy fakes are horrible people, but I certainly don't agree with buying counterfeits in any way.
Okay, think about this scenario:
We are all purse-lovers here from this form, we are all somewhat addicted to purses/handbags. We love certain brand, we work hard and try our best to save for the bag(s) we want.
For example, I want 3 bags, and it's hard for me to choose, I only have the funds to buy one, and finally I choose the one works best for me and take it home.
But somehow the urges to buy more kicks in within weeks if not days, but it's not realistic for me to buy another bag given the short time frame. So by buying a replica bag, it somewhat eliminates the urges to overspend.
I know it does not make any sense to some people. But it makes sense to me.
I don't buy fake bags because honestly I don't know where to buy them (I live in Toronto), and I don't trust the online shopping from unofficial sites, so many schemes and hassle, but if I see a good quality replica in a store I'm not sure if I can resist, but I would feel embarrassed to walk in that store, grrrr...it's just hard for me....
Happiness is not about how much you have, but how little you need.
We are all purse-lovers here from this form, we are all somewhat addicted to purses/handbags. We love certain brand, we work hard and try our best to save for the bag(s) we want.
For example, I want 3 bags, and it's hard for me to choose, I only have the funds to buy one, and finally I choose the one works best for me and take it home.
But somehow the urges to buy more kicks in within weeks if not days, but it's not realistic for me to buy another bag given the short time frame. So by buying a replica bag, it somewhat eliminates the urges to overspend.
I know it does not make any sense to some people. But it makes sense to me.
I don't buy fake bags because honestly I don't know where to buy them (I live in Toronto), and I don't trust the online shopping from unofficial sites, so many schemes and hassle, but if I see a good quality replica in a store I'm not sure if I can resist, but I would feel embarrassed to walk in that store, grrrr...it's just hard for me....
Happiness is not about how much you have, but how little you need.
I hear you sweetie! I agree that some people buy replicas because they cannot afford the real thing but love the look of the high end designer bags. Honestly I don't care because I know what I am carrying and really that is all that matters. Some places I go I can guarantee you they think my bags are replicas. Doesn't bother me and neither do the fakes. To each his own really! You do You - I'll do Me!
Sent from my iPhone using PurseForum
I honestly don't get it
I'd rather wait and buy the real thing, but that's just me. Again, I don't want to be insensitive to the plight of the less fortunate, and I can see that they can't afford the real thing but like the look, so they buy the replicas... but I cannot agree with them supporting an illegal industry. I think they would be better off buying an authentic bag from a cheaper designer that has a similar design (if they really like just the look), or just buy authentic pre-loved at a much cheaper price.
I honestly don't get it
Again, I don't want to be insensitive to the plight of the less fortunate, and I can see that they can't afford the real thing but like the look, so they buy the replicas... but I cannot agree with them supporting an illegal industry. I think they would be better off buying an authentic bag from a cheaper designer that has a similar design (if they really like just the look), or just buy authentic pre-loved at a much cheaper price.
Did not say I approve - I just don't put to much thought to it. There are a lot of things I don't approve of but I have learned with age not to worry about things I cannot control.
Sent from my iPhone using PurseForum
For sure. The point of this thread was to speculate on the topic of why people buy fake designer items though, so it's only natural people will talk much about it, and some would be passionate about certain issues that are tied to the topic.
I think how you feel about it is perfectly fine, but you must also understand that other people probably have different feelings and views about the topic and other things tied to it, so it's more of a live and let live mentality. If people are passionate about not supporting an illegal industry and would like to express that, then so be it. If people don't care, then so be it.
ETA: I never said YOU approved of buying counterfeit... My exact words were"... can see that they can't afford the real thing but like the look, so they buy the replicas... but I cannot agree with them supporting an illegal industry". All I said was that I personally cannot agree with those who support an illegal industry (those would be the ones buying counterfeit), and I just cannot get behind the idea of them doing what they do. I just wanted to clarify that.
Last edited:
Nancii
As far as I know good fakes aren't usually available in stores. There are replica handbag sites though that recommend online sellers like spotbags.cn and onlinehandbagreview...(spelling?)
I really don't know how good or bad these really are but I came across this when I was trying to figure out the differences between real and fake.
I personally don't judge anyone for buying fakes. I don't see it as "stealing" either. You still pay money for it, it is just that someone else manufactured it.
There was a time when it wasn't illegal to copy bag designs, or rather there was no law yet because it was so new. I would have more sympathy for fashion houses if their prices were reasonable like they used to be, but to say you either pay 5000 for bag X or you won't be "allowed" to carry this design is quite drastic.
One reason I don't feel like I want to get a fake bag is the warranty that comes with the bag and brand. The fact that they can fix it up for you if there is a problem. Carrying a fake might also feel a bit weird...like you can't enjoy it as much because you know it is a fake.
Then it is against the law, and even though I have mixed feelings about certain laws, I still abide by them because it isn't worth getting into trouble.
I think buying pre owned bags from a trusted site like Malleries is an option (I like the 90's Chanel bags
or buying inspired by.
Some inspired by bags actually look almost exactly the same, like the Italian handbags on ebay. Just they don't carry the logo. I'm sure the quality isn't exactly the same but it could help to carry the inspired by bag until you can afford the real one. It will also be a good test drive.
As far as I know good fakes aren't usually available in stores. There are replica handbag sites though that recommend online sellers like spotbags.cn and onlinehandbagreview...(spelling?)
I really don't know how good or bad these really are but I came across this when I was trying to figure out the differences between real and fake.
I personally don't judge anyone for buying fakes. I don't see it as "stealing" either. You still pay money for it, it is just that someone else manufactured it.
There was a time when it wasn't illegal to copy bag designs, or rather there was no law yet because it was so new. I would have more sympathy for fashion houses if their prices were reasonable like they used to be, but to say you either pay 5000 for bag X or you won't be "allowed" to carry this design is quite drastic.
One reason I don't feel like I want to get a fake bag is the warranty that comes with the bag and brand. The fact that they can fix it up for you if there is a problem. Carrying a fake might also feel a bit weird...like you can't enjoy it as much because you know it is a fake.
Then it is against the law, and even though I have mixed feelings about certain laws, I still abide by them because it isn't worth getting into trouble.
I think buying pre owned bags from a trusted site like Malleries is an option (I like the 90's Chanel bags
or buying inspired by.Some inspired by bags actually look almost exactly the same, like the Italian handbags on ebay. Just they don't carry the logo. I'm sure the quality isn't exactly the same but it could help to carry the inspired by bag until you can afford the real one. It will also be a good test drive.
As I stated above to each his own. Which is what I was stating for Nancii. Chill out as I am not saying it's right, wrong or indifferent.
Be Blessed MoNikki
You do know telling someone to chill out will probably get the opposite effect, right?
I'm not one of those people, but I've seen it in the workplace happen quite often.Anyway - from my end, I just want to make sure my views are clear. I reiterate, I emphasize, I do what needs to be done to ensure they are clear.
So, at the end of this, what are the takeaway points then, after all is said and done?
I don't want it to seem that we were engaged in this for nothing.
- I don't support buying counterfeits in any shape or form.
- I am passionate about not supporting counterfeits
- I think people who buy counterfeits are not horrible people, but to me, they are misinformed. They could be buying lovely authentic pieces for around the same price as their counterfeits - either preloved, or from cheaper designers that may carry similar handbag designs. Depending on their situation, they could even save up for a lovely brand-new authentic item full-price. If not, then the first two options I mentioned are what I support.
Those 3 are what drive my responses in this thread.
I'm sure you are mature enough to not take any personal offense to any of the responses here (I surely haven't). I just want to make my stance clear. It's fine if people don't feel the same, but I'm going to keep expressing my views.
This post wasn't just meant for you, by the way. It's more of a blanket statement with regards to how I feel about this topic, and counterfeits, in general.
Have a nice day
- that's a sincere smile and greeting, btw. You probably don't know me well enough here in the forum, but I do like engaging in these types of discussions without ill feelings.Let me restate my point:
I only own authentic bags at this point, I can afford designer bags, but not as many as I want. I'm very tempted to buy a replica bag, but a lot of things hold me back e.g. quality, moral, scams. Also I do care what other people think of me. So I haven't had the courage to "cross the line" yet, but I'm tempted.
Happiness is not about how much you have, but how little you need.
Your honesty is refreshing. I will, however, say this... don't go over to the dark sidddeee!!!
You do know telling someone to chill out will probably get the opposite effect, right?
Anyway - from my end, I just want to make sure my views are clear. I reiterate, I emphasize, I do what needs to be done to ensure they are clear.
So, at the end of this, what are the takeaway points then, after all is said and done?
I don't want it to seem that we were engaged in this for nothing.
- I don't support buying counterfeits in any shape or form.
- I am passionate about not supporting counterfeits
- I think people who buy counterfeits are not horrible people, but to me, they are misinformed. They could be buying lovely authentic pieces for around the same price as their counterfeits - either preloved, or from cheaper designers that may carry similar handbag designs. Depending on their situation, they could even save up for a lovely brand-new authentic item full-price. If not, then the first two options I mentioned are what I support.
Those 3 are what drive my responses in this thread.
I'm sure you are mature enough to not take any personal offense to any of the responses here (I surely haven't). I just want to make my stance clear. It's fine if people don't feel the same, but I'm going to keep expressing my views.
This post wasn't just meant for you, by the way. It's more of a blanket statement with regards to how I feel about this topic, and counterfeits, in general.
Have a nice day
You're fine dear no offense taken at all. . .we all are different people from different places! We will not agree on everything - heck I barely agree with my husband. I like reading these threads - sometimes I comment sometimes I do not. I know if I do comment there will be someone who will comment back. I smile because I'm always going to do me no matter what. Smooches dear.
Be Blessed MoNikki
I knew what you were saying. Just saying if that's what you want to do it's all good. No worries.
Be Blessed MoNikki
Following this thread I'm really starting to think the whole question is loaded like a landmine. "Why do people buy fake designer bags or fake designer anything?" Anyone who honestly admits that they do and explains why, which is the point of this question btw, is accused of stealing, a supporter of an illegal industry, or given the somewhat indifferent "everyone has a right to their own lifestyle but I personally don't do it" disclaimer or the "I used to but stopped so I'm all good"...none of which is an answer to the original question.
I mean the bottom line is because either the person didn't know it was fake or they simply like the bag, the price, and enjoy wearing it. As for all the negative implication attached to it, if it bothered them, they wouldn't buy it in the first place. And if they were gifted the fake, ultimately the same answer. It either bothers you or it doesn't - how complex can it be?
As for the rest of us responding, how about, do you feel better about yourself, pat yourself on the back, for not wearing a fake/replica/counterfeit when you see someone else wearing one? Do you regard that person with shock, disdain, outrage, pity, indifference, gotcha!, secret bag twin? (just had to add that last one). Personally, I think I fall along the lines of "gotcha" 'cause I'm pretty clueless.
And what about the whole idea of authentic but stolen bags? Have any of you bargain hunters ever wonder if the great NWT deal on Ebay is actually a stolen (authentic) bag? We've all heard of gangs targeting stores and leaving by the truckload, could one of them be the very bag you're carrying?
Frankly I'm more curious about who and why people steal office supplies (rhetorical question).
I mean the bottom line is because either the person didn't know it was fake or they simply like the bag, the price, and enjoy wearing it. As for all the negative implication attached to it, if it bothered them, they wouldn't buy it in the first place. And if they were gifted the fake, ultimately the same answer. It either bothers you or it doesn't - how complex can it be?
As for the rest of us responding, how about, do you feel better about yourself, pat yourself on the back, for not wearing a fake/replica/counterfeit when you see someone else wearing one? Do you regard that person with shock, disdain, outrage, pity, indifference, gotcha!, secret bag twin? (just had to add that last one). Personally, I think I fall along the lines of "gotcha" 'cause I'm pretty clueless.
And what about the whole idea of authentic but stolen bags? Have any of you bargain hunters ever wonder if the great NWT deal on Ebay is actually a stolen (authentic) bag? We've all heard of gangs targeting stores and leaving by the truckload, could one of them be the very bag you're carrying?
Frankly I'm more curious about who and why people steal office supplies (rhetorical question).