Why Do People Buy Fake Designer Bags Or Fake Designer Anything?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

One more point I forgot to add..

If a saw a man wearing a fake rolex, I wouldn't judge him for it by 'not taking him seriously' Same goes with women, I wouldn't think any different of them if they carried a fake handbag! lol

Good for you. I'm the opposite. I can't take people who wear fake Rolex and fake designer bags seriously. I prefer to see people wearing real Michael Kors watch or H&M bags
 
I'd also like to add that just yesterday she proudly showed me her new Fossil bag and it was immediately apparent it was also a fake. I'm pretty sure it was actually pleather, because even though Fossil is not a high end designer at all, they still use nice, quality leather and this thing just felt like a dead fish in the hand.

I'm just curious how long before it, too, lands on eBay with the title of "authentic." Sigh.

They make fake Fossil? WTH?
 
his angel said:
i have a story that would be a great method to either induce vomitting or crying!!
yetsurday i was at a store buying some socks for my son. I was waiting in line to pay when my eyes caught a lovely burgendy paddington on the arm of the lady in front of me. As she didnt look like anyone who would be carrying such an expensive bag; I was really interested. Not that I am catagorizing people now as "expensive bag material" or not but you can almost tell by the way a person dresses and takes care of themselves if thsi person is likely to be holding an expensive bag or not. This person I saw was not. I started some small talk with her and i admired her bag (i was holding my whiskey paddington at that time too). I asked her where she got it. I was shocked!! On my way out of the store I caught another glimpse of her bag and almost went into tears!!!

That's a dangerous and unfortunate way to think about folks. I recall my time as a freshman a Duke. I lived next to Ralph Lauren kids, and Ben Qualye ,and they looked like they had just gotten out of bed most times, really shabby and drove VWs. I think people with a certain amount of exposure and experience realize that many people who are well off simply don't display their wealth.
i think you have a good point here. I worked in a very, very high end boutique in Los Angeles, and my colleagues were scampering across the floor to get (and sell to) the women who were dressed head to toe in designer duds...they wanted the sale so bad - often there wasn't much behind it though. I sat back, and greeted the people who were dressed a lot more "real"...sometimes quite shabby, but they had an air, if you will...and guess who had the wealthiest clientele list? moi....because there is a large group of people who have SO much money, they really don't care what anyone thinks...and they are quite secure, reminds me of what you said about the Lauren kids...interesting flip side of all of this, right?
 
I've been reading this blog for a while now and got sucked into this topic and just wanted to share my 2 cents. I personally don't care what a person carries, be it real, knock off, or handmade, so long as they love it the way any handbag should be loved. :smile1:

My real disgust on the topic was inflamed just the other day while shopping for a new bag and a coworker began bragging about her own collection. Now, I won't say I own any of the high end brands because, honestly, I can't afford LV or Hermes or Bottega Veneta (lowly 911 dispatcher making menial wages but because I help people and love that, I stay). However, I have amassed some nice bags in my time (a Marc Jacobs clutch, some Kate Spades, a Michael Kors that I adore, and some Dooneys and nicer Coach bags... nothing too special but they all are understated, timelessly elegant and lovely to look at). So coworker, whom I already dislike because of her "anything you can do, I can do better" attitude on EVERYTHING, started going on about all of her "authentic" Louis Vuitton's she'd purchased. Come to find out, she had a friend stationed in Korea and he was able to get them for just a few hundred dollars (authentic...riiiiiight). She continued on about her fake Coach bags or something, I'm not really sure -- I'd pretty well tuned her out at this point -- until she proudly remarked, "I had some nice fake Coach bags my friend bought for about twenty dollars that I was able to sell on eBay and pass off as legit for several hundred."

At this point, I stopped what I was doing, slowly turned to her, and said flatly, "You're a terrible person." Because that's what she is. (If I may have just offended anyone, take comfort in the fact that it's okay because it really is true. Her snotty attitude, the way she inserts herself into everyone else's conversations, asking blatanly ovious questions meant to steer conversations back toward herself -- she just cemented it all in stone admitting to that).

My point is she. She is what makes counterfeit items so bad. The fact that someone, somewhere, duped another by passing off a replica as authentic, forfeiting their integrity in the process and undermining another's trust in others. If they get away with it once, as she did, they'll almost certainly try it again, and again, and again, as she did, chipping away at society's ability to believe the word of the fellow man.

I can't believe she did that. :| Lying about that fake bag. And you are right, that is terrible.
 
It's interesting, I've kept statistics in an AT thread here for more than three years. Of the total 500 sellers there are two groups, one sell authentic and one sell fakes. The two groups never cross, those selling fakes continue to sell fakes over and over. And those selling authentic continue with this. The statistics are for one brand only though.
 
it's interesting, i've kept statistics in an at thread here for more than three years. Of the total 500 sellers there are two groups, one sell authentic and one sell fakes. The two groups never cross, those selling fakes continue to sell fakes over and over. And those selling authentic continue with this. The statistics are for one brand only though.

lv?
 
I've been reading this blog for a while now and got sucked into this topic and just wanted to share my 2 cents. I personally don't care what a person carries, be it real, knock off, or handmade, so long as they love it the way any handbag should be loved. :smile1:

My real disgust on the topic was inflamed just the other day while shopping for a new bag and a coworker began bragging about her own collection. Now, I won't say I own any of the high end brands because, honestly, I can't afford LV or Hermes or Bottega Veneta (lowly 911 dispatcher making menial wages but because I help people and love that, I stay). However, I have amassed some nice bags in my time (a Marc Jacobs clutch, some Kate Spades, a Michael Kors that I adore, and some Dooneys and nicer Coach bags... nothing too special but they all are understated, timelessly elegant and lovely to look at). So coworker, whom I already dislike because of her "anything you can do, I can do better" attitude on EVERYTHING, started going on about all of her "authentic" Louis Vuitton's she'd purchased. Come to find out, she had a friend stationed in Korea and he was able to get them for just a few hundred dollars (authentic...riiiiiight). She continued on about her fake Coach bags or something, I'm not really sure -- I'd pretty well tuned her out at this point -- until she proudly remarked, "I had some nice fake Coach bags my friend bought for about twenty dollars that I was able to sell on eBay and pass off as legit for several hundred."

At this point, I stopped what I was doing, slowly turned to her, and said flatly, "You're a terrible person." Because that's what she is. (If I may have just offended anyone, take comfort in the fact that it's okay because it really is true. Her snotty attitude, the way she inserts herself into everyone else's conversations, asking blatanly ovious questions meant to steer conversations back toward herself -- she just cemented it all in stone admitting to that).

My point is she. She is what makes counterfeit items so bad. The fact that someone, somewhere, duped another by passing off a replica as authentic, forfeiting their integrity in the process and undermining another's trust in others. If they get away with it once, as she did, they'll almost certainly try it again, and again, and again, as she did, chipping away at society's ability to believe the word of the fellow man.
You have a very important job and a wonderful attitude! Nice to see!!!
Your co-worker is an A$$. Period.
 
This may be a bit of a different approach to knock-offs, but I've bought a few to test out whether I really like the item enough to get the real thing. Never a bag, just accessories. Bought an H clic clac a few years ago to see if I would actually wear it enough to justify spending $630 on the real thing. And guess what - I wore it until it broke and then bought the real thing! Right now I'm doing this with the H Constance belt - I didn't buy a knock-off exactly, but got the C Wonder initial belt with an "H" initial buckle. I've gotten a ton of use out of it and am now on a hunt for the real deal. But other items - a Michelle watch, a trendy pair of Chanel sunglasses - I discovered I didn't wear very much and was glad I didn't buy the real deal.
 
Before buying a real LV papillon, I bought a fake for a little over $100. I really wanted one, but with a family to support, I couldn't justify the price. The zipper split from the bag after a year or so. I also bought a DB that was clearly copying the white and multi LV style. That held up a little better.

That was 10 years ago.

I have a 2 used LV bags and one new and the quality difference is huge. I've had my papillon at least 2 years and it doesn't look like it has aged at all. You get what you pay for.

I wouldn't buy a fake designer bag today. But, in my opinion, lower end designers often copy higher end designers. Not that different. But, I think outright copying is wrong because it is theft of intellectual property. But, I don't look down on people who buy fakes. As far as whether or not the factories that make fakes exploit the workers, it is pretty likely any cheap bag was made by people who were not paid well for their work.
 
i think you have a good point here. I worked in a very, very high end boutique in Los Angeles, and my colleagues were scampering across the floor to get (and sell to) the women who were dressed head to toe in designer duds...they wanted the sale so bad - often there wasn't much behind it though. I sat back, and greeted the people who were dressed a lot more "real"...sometimes quite shabby, but they had an air, if you will...and guess who had the wealthiest clientele list? moi....because there is a large group of people who have SO much money, they really don't care what anyone thinks...and they are quite secure, reminds me of what you said about the Lauren kids...interesting flip side of all of this, right?

Yep. I worked a long time ago with an older gentleman who was from a venerable wealthy Canadian family (to say he was "a real character" would be quite an understatement) and I remember an awesome thing he said to me once on this subject: "New money drives a new Mercedes. Old money still drives the '78 Ford station wagon with the back bumper tied on with rope."
 
You have a very important job and a wonderful attitude! Nice to see!!!
Your co-worker is an A$$. Period.

Thank you so much for the kind words! I've held many diverse jobs in my time and I can honestly say, being a 911 dispatcher is the single most fulfilling one I've ever had. And that's stacked against some pretty good/cool jobs (high-paying govt contracting job, middle school teacher, hotel concierge, arms dealer, to name a few). I turned my nose up at being a dispatcher for a long time before I gave it a shot; best employment decision I've ever made, and it humbled me quite a bit to fall in love with a job I once considered beneath me.

I've learned to never judge others based on their possessions (occasionally I catch myself caught up in it though...it's just animal nature to be competitive). My mother also taught me that a person's clothes have no bearing on who they are. She grew up in a poor single-parent household, sewing her own clothes as a teen and later as a mother (and ours clothes, too), but she carried herself so well that it didn't matter if she lived in a mansion or trailer park. She had grace and still does. And if she sewed up a handbag for me, I'd carry it more proudly than any of my designer bags (and use it to beat the ever-living crap out of anyone who ridiculed it. I'm not so sure she passed her grace on to me :p).

A person's handbag choice is about as important to me as a person's decision to marry another. If it's love, it's love, so let it be. :)
 
Yep. I worked a long time ago with an older gentleman who was from a venerable wealthy Canadian family (to say he was "a real character" would be quite an understatement) and I remember an awesome thing he said to me once on this subject: "New money drives a new Mercedes. Old money still drives the '78 Ford station wagon with the back bumper tied on with rope."

That's so awesome. I bet you have a wealth of stories from your time with him and I'd be willing to bet he was a very entertaining and insightful individual. :) The older generations are the best to spend time with, IMO.
 
Top