Which white bag? Dionysus bamboo or Sylvie?

[maryg1]

I’ve been thinking about adding a white bag in my collection for some time now.
I’ve come down to 2 models: Gucci Dionysus with bamboo top handle and Gucci Sylvie top handle.
It won’t be obviously used as an everyday bag.
Things to consider: I’m planning to add a super mini Dionysus in denim (too cute) and a small Dionysus (still undecided about the color).
While I’m not a lover of black top handle bags (I only have a Kelly 28 black box and toile, all black leather Kellys look like doctor’s bags to me), I find the black top handle Sylvie gorgeous, so I might consider getting it as my black bag.
If I like a bag, I don’t mind having duplicates in different sizes/colors.
I’d appreciate to hear your thoughts, and if you have experiences with both models (pro and cons) I’m very happy to hear them.
Thank you!

 

[papertiger]

I think the the Dionysus + BTH + tri-colour a bit busy so prefer the Sylvie

 

[ladyet]

iirc, the Dionysus is a rather heavy bag, so that'd be a turn off for me.

i also enjoy the look of both bags, but I think the tricolor prominence might pigeon hole you in terms of of styling. it seems like a very nautical appropriate bag, almost too much so. since the colors are accents on the Sylvie, might be able to wear with more.