Which wedding band would you choose?
- Thread starter trf
- Start date
First one, 100%. It just looks more like a wedding band. The others are pretty too, and I especially love the last one, but they would make better rings for any other purpose vs. a wedding band. Me personally, I'd choose something classic and versatile for the band because you'll be wearing it all the time and for a long time! The other rings are pretty as normal jewelry.
Agree with @lalame. Could always get the others over time for variety. For example, when I travel, I often switch to another ring that has a flatter profile because I feel it will be damaged less than my e-ring with prongs. Good luck and let us know what you end up deciding!
I voted for #1. It looks so beautiful with your e-ring and it 'fits' perfectly together. The other choices just don't look right, in my opinion.
I only like #1 with your solitaire, and I agree with others that the other bands are great alternates when you don't want to wear the solitaire set. However, I think the stones in #1 are a little large to go with your solitaire and kind of overwhelm it. I'd recommend trying something like a 7 stone band with .10 ct stones which would be better in proportion to your solitaire.
Of the choices given, I prefer the first band. However, I also think the stones compete with your solitaire. Maybe try a similar one with smaller stones. If you’re wondering what a band with smaller stones might look like, here’s mine for reference. It is a full eternity but you still get the picture. I would recommend starting perhaps by looking at a seven stone band in a carat weight similar to the 5 stone. Good luck.
Last edited:
Thank you all for your input! Plot twist- I’ve decided to go with none of them!! After posting this, I fell in love with an Argyle light pink diamond eternity band in rose gold 
. A classic style that I can never get tired of but with a subtle, special twist. I love how the pink is subtle, not too pink that it detracts from the solitaire but enough to be a little different. 
Now I’m just deciding which width I like more. One is slightly thicker than the other.
. A classic style that I can never get tired of but with a subtle, special twist. I love how the pink is subtle, not too pink that it detracts from the solitaire but enough to be a little different. Now I’m just deciding which width I like more. One is slightly thicker than the other.
Last edited: