Great choices! Personally I like the Day/Date Presidential...classic! I do like the Pearlmaster posted by @nvie. But for a long term watch you can't go wrong with the Presidential. As far as size is concerned...I'm in the older tPF member category. The older you get the harder it is to read the time. I now wear bigger watches so I can READ the damn time! I own a 33, 37, a 36mm size watch and find the 36mm perfect. I have small wrists but it works.
Does the Presidential come in a 34mm...might be worth it to try this size for piece of mind. Good luck and keep us posted.
Thankyou so much for the feedback! Unfortunately the daydate presidential only comes in 36mm or 40mm. So the 36 is quite bulky. Imagine if they released it in 34mm one it would sell like hot cakes hahhaa.
Do you have any photos of your 36,37mm watches?
Thankyou!!!