I highly recommend getting a tote. It's great having a bag you can just throw over your shoulder and go since both of your bigger bags are handheld. You should go to the boutique and try them on. I love the Batignolles Horizontal, but when I tried it on, the style was too wide on me. I didn't like how the Batignolles Verticial looked on me either. Then I tried on the Cabas Piano and it turned out to the the perfect size! So, before you decide, go try them all on, if you can.