Which style in Peony?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#31
PurseUOut said:
Thank you so much for the pics! We have such similar taste :smile:

I have a love/hate relationship with the rogue - adore the look and leather but not my favorite to wear. To be honest I haven't found one 1941 bag that "fits" me yet like those in the Coach New York line. I have the navy turnlock edie and it is one of my favorite bags. The peony edie is gorgeous and I love the silver hardware - very fresh and youthful looking. You won't be disappointed with that choice!

The peony tea rose rogue w/ snakeskin rivets that will be included in the next phase of the sale, so that's another option.
Click to expand...

Welcome! Sometimes it can help with making a decision.

So you have a Rogue but it's not functional for you or too heavy?

I do like the Turnlock Edie...it's a bit dressier than the Edie 31. But I worry the chain straps may bother me with noise etc.

Thanks again for your thoughts and input!
 
#32
PurseUOut said:
Thank you so much for the pics! We have such similar taste :smile:

I have a love/hate relationship with the rogue - adore the look and leather but not my favorite to wear. To be honest I haven't found one 1941 bag that "fits" me yet like those in the Coach New York line. I have the navy turnlock edie and it is one of my favorite bags. The peony edie is gorgeous and I love the silver hardware - very fresh and youthful looking. You won't be disappointed with that choice!

The peony tea rose rogue w/ snakeskin rivets that will be included in the next phase of the sale, so that's another option.
Click to expand...

H there, so I'm guessing the next phase of the sale will include some new items? Do you know what else is on there? Percentage-wise, will it be pretty much the same as now, so 40% for the rogues? I have the peony rose rogue w/snakeskin rivets I got for 40% off, that's getting delivered tomorrow; seems like they accidentally included it in there during the early VIP access. Trying to decide if I should get something else, or hold off for the next phase of the sale!
 
#33
shillinggirl88 said:
Wow thanks for the input thus far everyone! I am quite surprised. I know they are a more substantial handbag. Ever since this bag came out I am back and forth on if it is a bag I see as a "me" bag. I have had a few and sold most. But of course I had to look at it today and the store that is closest to me had every single Peony I wanted to look at.

Here is me earlier with it at the store. I wasn't dressed up or anything and look a bit serious ;)
Click to expand...
I really like the Rogue on you !! But I am partial to the Rogue as its one of my favorite Coach bags . I so wish I could own it , but its just to heavy for me :(
Good luck with your decision :)
 
#35
shillinggirl88 said:
Welcome! Sometimes it can help with making a decision.

So you have a Rogue but it's not functional for you or too heavy?

I do like the Turnlock Edie...it's a bit dressier than the Edie 31. But I worry the chain straps may bother me with noise etc.

Thanks again for your thoughts and input!
Click to expand...

The rogue isn't as heavy as it is fussy/not functional. I don't really know how the handles are supposed to lay and they are awkward when trying to retrieve items out of the openside of the flap. I also find the strap drop to be a tad too short for me. Otherwise it's a nice bag, just not for "me".

I don't find the Edie noisy, but the metal Coach fob is looped around the chain strap and not attached to any part of the bag. So when you put it down it tends to shift/move among the strap. I really enjoy the functionality of the Edie. Very easy to wear for a medium size bag that doesn't seem too big. Can't wait to see your update on what you finally decide!
 
  • Like
Reactions: finer_woman and tealocean
#36
lovingmybags said:
H there, so I'm guessing the next phase of the sale will include some new items? Do you know what else is on there? Percentage-wise, will it be pretty much the same as now, so 40% for the rogues? I have the peony rose rogue w/snakeskin rivets I got for 40% off, that's getting delivered tomorrow; seems like they accidentally included it in there during the early VIP access. Trying to decide if I should get something else, or hold off for the next phase of the sale!
Click to expand...

Yes the next phase will include some new items and most likely an additional discount (~10%) of the existing inventory. I am not sure of everything that will be included, but a good indicator would be if the item has "Online Exclusive" in its photo on the website. I haven't seen any 1941 items, especially Rogues go for more than 50% during a SAS. But then again the bandit and double swaggers are 50% off now so who knows they may go lower if they don't sell out.

You can hold out for hopefully more discount but there is always a chance the item will sell out before the next phase. You can call into JAX, give them the item number and ask for the inventory of that item. Also, E-b-a-t-e-s is having 15% off Coach today, so that is effectively 55%-65% off if you order online today.
 
  • Like
Reactions: harley13 and lovingmybags
#37
PurseUOut said:
Yes the next phase will include some new items and most likely an additional discount (~10%) of the existing inventory. I am not sure of everything that will be included, but a good indicator would be if the item has "Online Exclusive" in its photo on the website. I haven't seen any 1941 items, especially Rogues go for more than 50% during a SAS. But then again the bandit and double swaggers are 50% off now so who knows they may go lower if they don't sell out.

You can hold out for hopefully more discount but there is always a chance the item will sell out before the next phase. You can call into JAX, give them the item number and ask for the inventory of that item. Also, E-b-a-t-e-s is having 15% off Coach today, so that is effectively 55%-65% off if you order online today.
Click to expand...

Thank you for this! I don't see the peony tea rose rogue with snakeskin rivets as an online exclusive; did your SA give you the info that it'll be included? I guess the next phase will contain a smattering of different items, possibly some old stock too?
 
#38
lovingmybags said:
Thank you for this! I don't see the peony tea rose rogue with snakeskin rivets as an online exclusive; did your SA give you the info that it'll be included? I guess the next phase will contain a smattering of different items, possibly some old stock too?
Click to expand...

Yes, she did. Actually the peony TR rogue was in the sale section and I asked about the price. That is when she looked in the system and said that the bag will be marked down 40% off in the next phase of the sale, but was willing to give me the discount early. :)

I'm really hoping they bring back some of the rogue satchels and possibly regular size saddle bags. Missed out on those!
 
  • Like
Reactions: lovingmybags
#40
tealocean said:
Both are so beautiful! The Bandit looks especially comfortable to carry!
Click to expand...

Thank you! Yes, the bandit is amazing, like wearing a big pillow! lol the Rogue feels much comfortable with the matching novelty strap, otherwise not so much. Not to mention the bandit's also lighter! Given the size difference, the rogue's going back, but both are great to look at. Peony's a really nice color :smile:
 
  • Like
Reactions: BagsRGreat, tealocean and whateve
#41
PurseUOut said:
Yes the next phase will include some new items and most likely an additional discount (~10%) of the existing inventory. I am not sure of everything that will be included, but a good indicator would be if the item has "Online Exclusive" in its photo on the website. I haven't seen any 1941 items, especially Rogues go for more than 50% during a SAS. But then again the bandit and double swaggers are 50% off now so who knows they may go lower if they don't sell out.

You can hold out for hopefully more discount but there is always a chance the item will sell out before the next phase. You can call into JAX, give them the item number and ask for the inventory of that item. Also, E-b-a-t-e-s is having 15% off Coach today, so that is effectively 55%-65% off if you order online today.
Click to expand...
Thanks for posting about the extra discount. I haven't used them before but 15% is great even if you have to wait a while.
 
#42
PurseUOut said:
The rogue isn't as heavy as it is fussy/not functional. I don't really know how the handles are supposed to lay and they are awkward when trying to retrieve items out of the openside of the flap. I also find the strap drop to be a tad too short for me. Otherwise it's a nice bag, just not for "me".

I don't find the Edie noisy, but the metal Coach fob is looped around the chain strap and not attached to any part of the bag. So when you put it down it tends to shift/move among the strap. I really enjoy the functionality of the Edie. Very easy to wear for a medium size bag that doesn't seem too big. Can't wait to see your update on what you finally decide!
Click to expand...
Well, I went back today super quick just to look and no plans to decide / buy. (and I was good I didn't) For me I think it comes down to Edie 31 and Rogue. Big price difference and styles pretty different. I still wonder if the Peony color or any light pink is better with a lighter style - Rogue is so substantial.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tealocean and harley13
#43
lovingmybags said:
Thank you! Yes, the bandit is amazing, like wearing a big pillow! lol the Rogue feels much comfortable with the matching novelty strap, otherwise not so much. Not to mention the bandit's also lighter! Given the size difference, the rogue's going back, but both are great to look at. Peony's a really nice color :smile:
Click to expand...
That's exciting you already figured out which one is a keeper! I've never tried either of them on but the Bandit looks like one I'd love too. Yes, that color is beautiful!
 
  • Like
Reactions: lovingmybags
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top