Which style in Peony?

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

#17
whateve said:
Rogue or Chelsea. I've heard that the color looks more peach than pink on certain styles. The Chelsea is a lot cheaper and probably lighter weight. It isn't 1941, though, and is going to become a factory style.

Don't get a Rogue because everyone else loves it. You have to love it.
Click to expand...
Whateve, do you know if the Chelsea crossbody style will be MFF too? I want more colors, like the Forest hunter green they made in the past.
 
#18
shillinggirl88 said:
Thanks! Of course I tried all on and took pics! So here are the others. I'm funny that way mod shots help me.
Click to expand...
They all look great on you, but I especially like the last Edie on you. It was interesting how you said the color is feminine for a Rogue. Is the Rouge thought to be a more masculine bag? When I first saw pictures of the Rogue that style didn't look feminine enough for me until I saw certain colors and close ups of that leather that make it more me. I still don't have one. I think I like curvier bags. How do you feel when you carry each of them, and how comfortable do they feel? I imagine the Chelsea and then the Edie are more comfortable, but that shade looks beautiful on the Rogue too! (I am not much help, sorry!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: whateve
#19
I like the rogue and the gold hardware and second would be the chelsea. I originally was going to say Edie with chains but after seeing it hang, it looks uncomfortable. I may need to add that rogue to my list. I ordered the dusty rose bandit with tea rose but it is a different pink.
 
#20
tealocean said:
Whateve, do you know if the Chelsea crossbody style will be MFF too? I want more colors, like the Forest hunter green they made in the past.
Click to expand...
I haven't heard. I read on the forum that the Chelsea was going to be on SAS because it was being discontinued as a FP line, and would become a factory style. At the time I read it, I assumed it just meant the larger one, but it could have meant all of them. However, on SAS, all colors of the Chelsea hobo are marked down, but some colors of the crossbody aren't, which makes me think it isn't being discontinued.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tealocean
#22
Bagmedic said:
I like the rogue and the gold hardware and second would be the chelsea. I originally was going to say Edie with chains but after seeing it hang, it looks uncomfortable. I may need to add that rogue to my list. I ordered the dusty rose bandit with tea rose but it is a different pink.
Click to expand...
I am considering that exact Edie, but had the same thought after seeing the picture. Is it uncomfortable?
 
#26
whateve said:
I haven't heard. I read on the forum that the Chelsea was going to be on SAS because it was being discontinued as a FP line, and would become a factory style. At the time I read it, I assumed it just meant the larger one, but it could have meant all of them. However, on SAS, all colors of the Chelsea hobo are marked down, but some colors of the crossbody aren't, which makes me think it isn't being discontinued.
Click to expand...
Thank you! I hope they'll bring something like "Forest" back. I looked for it used for a while but haven't been looking lately (in order to stick to a real ban ;) ).
 
#30
Thank you so much for the pics! We have such similar taste :)

I have a love/hate relationship with the rogue - adore the look and leather but not my favorite to wear. To be honest I haven't found one 1941 bag that "fits" me yet like those in the Coach New York line. I have the navy turnlock edie and it is one of my favorite bags. The peony edie is gorgeous and I love the silver hardware - very fresh and youthful looking. You won't be disappointed with that choice!

The peony tea rose rogue w/ snakeskin rivets that will be included in the next phase of the sale, so that's another option.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top