I vote for HH. I once had a Coach metallic hobo in silver, and I had the same problem as hippiechic described above - the only difference is that the color rubbed off after ONE week. I ended up returning it.
I have exactly the HH Havana hobo in pyrite as in the pic. So far I do not have anything to complain about, only compliments. And the tassel! I definitely think it gives you a more unique look.