Which Madison Exotic Sophia to get?!

[dancer4j]

Ok, I've made my mind up. I must have the Madison Exotic Sophia! Now I am debating on whether I want the black or the caramel. I have a checkbook that would look ok with the black, but I have no current checkbook to match the caramel. I prefer to have an actual checkbook, otherwise I would do the accordion wallet that matches. What to do!?

Attached some pics for those who aren't sure what each look like:

 

[RachelS4]

I just bought the black and love it.

 

[nursie]

i want the caramel, so i pick that one.

 

[lilitaly]

I vote Black!

 

[cosmogrrl]

I think the black looks plain. And the black croc and silver hardware had been done over and over.

The caramel is both new and eternally classy.

Then again, depends on what you wear. I'd say go by the hardware. If you wear gold jewelry, get the caramel. It would be beautiful with black or brown or anything. If you wear silver, get the black.

I have the caramel because there is ALWAYS another black bag. My black croc Alexandra might be my favorite bag ever. I am thinking of putting my black croc Mad carryall on ebay because it pales in comparison.

 

[dancer4j]

ahh, it's a tie! I prefer to wear silver jewelry. That's a good point, cosmogrrl. I didn't even think of that!

 

[dancer4j]

Question: does anyone have the matching accordion wallet in caramel? could I fit a checkbook and register in it? I don't have that many cards to keep.

 

[nyssa.]

Black! Such a classic colour. Also, you won't have to get a new checkbook hehe

 

[lovepochikitty]

I love the caramel/toffee one, the color is TDF.

 

[Headlighted]

Black!

 

[proffashionista]

you cannot lose with these choices. Go with the shade that you need more of..if that helps.

BTW, I own the toffee and the day I snipped her tags off and carried her, I got 3 compliments in the first HOUR! And more after that. The bag drapes beautifully with some use, too.

 

[NITE_FOXX]

i vote to get the toffee. its gorgeous!!! not a typical black bag it will look great with everything and stand out more.

 

[Joannek1717]

I am usually a basic black girl, but in this case, I think I like the toffee better. Which will go with more of your wardrobe???

 

[lizmil]

Black bags are always around, i vote for the brown.

 

[QnBee9]

Black.