I think it's hard to decide without knowing what style/size/leather of bag you would prefer.
IMO, which colour is cuter depend on the style of the bag.
Take an example, for an Evelyn, I think orange is cuter than BJ. But take a Bolide, I think BJ is cuter than orange. Generally, I would think with larger bags, BJ is cuter (orange would look too much), for a smaller size, the orange can add that extra pop to the bag.