I saw you railing against the metal nameplate!!! There’s such a breadth of opinion in the bag world, I love it!
See, I’m the other way, I love the square metal, but ONLY the text one! I dislike the square metal plate that says DOONEY above, BOURKE along the bottom and then has the duck in middle...and I don’t have a great reason. It’s just too much ‘negative space’ maybe? I prefer the old-school leather oval most of the time, but I acknowledge on some designs the leather nameplate would be very out of place. I love the plate that says DOONEY above, BOURKE below but has the...it’s like a coat of arms, I guess, between instead of the duck. And I think the plate that is just script, like the Barlows/Dawsons/etc have is just okay. It’s very tasteful but mine often catch on things and I fear tearing one off the bag.