Jewelry to me is a sunk cost; it is a luxury, for pure enjoyment.
Wearing jewelry is for me, it gives me an ear-to-ear smile because I love the piece.
I think when buying jewelry, if you mentally look at it as an investment, you may never buy the over-the-top, unique pieces you truly love. You will end up buying pieces that are "safe" and more "commonly known," such as Alhambra. The truly over-the-top, unique pieces have a limited audience; yet that is exactly what makes them super special!
Now... on to these earrings...
Looking at the earrings for me personally, it would not be something I would wear as I have wimpy ears and only wear studs.
However, looking at it as a piece of jewelry for someone who could wear them, I think the earrings are gorgeous. They are bold, stunning, and very artistic. I love love love the use of mixed cuts in jewelry, and the way she uses the baguettes next to the pears, rounds, and marquise cuts for the colored gemstones is gorgeous. It reminds me of the Tiffany Schlumberger Jasmine Breath of Spring necklace, which is a super super stunning piece to me. I can see these earrings in the same way. Since you already have rings, I am sure they will go great.
One final thought for what it's worth... I know we are here in the VCA forum, but to me, a well-rounded jewelry collection is more than just VCA and certainly more than a bunch of Alhambra. It seems you also love other non-VCA pieces, so I vote yes... if you love these earrings, get them! I am all for over-the-top, unique, statement pieces.
I also posted the iconic Schlumberger Jasmine necklace here for you. I think it's stunning, a flower theme. As I said, your earrings remind me of this gorgeous piece, but a more "contemporary, 21st century" version.
Just my thoughts to help you decide. Good luck!
View attachment 5364038