What feedback should I leave?

[Allisonfaye]

I just bought a Bbag from a reputable seller. I specifically asked if there were any scratches and she said no. There were two tiny ones but they are not a big deal. The bags is nice and I am happy with it. But, I was shocked that she crammed the bag into a box that was too small. I knew she wasn't including a box in the sale so that was ok but although I ordered a city, I thought it was going to be a first when I saw the box. I couldn't imagine how it could be in that small box. What feedback should I leave?

 

[Fendi213]

I would leave her postitve as she might not have seen the scratches herself, as you did say they were tiny. But you could add a comment saying that you felt it could have needed to be shipped in a larger box if you felt that it damaged the bag?

 

[HandbagAngel]

Did the "sloppy" shipping cause any damage? This seller must try to save money from shipping since now USPS charges rate per size of the box. But I agree, BBag is not cheap, she should ship it in a better way. I wouldn't give her a positive feedback. I would just leave her without a feedback.

 

[lorihmatthews]

I've had this happen to me before when a seller tried to cram an item in a box that was in my opinion too small. I felt like I should leave pos FB because the item was not damaged, so I said something like "item arrived quickly and described, but packed poorly." This might work in your situation.

 

[2starsonmyback]

I've had this happen to me before when a seller tried to cram an item in a box that was in my opinion too small. I felt like I should leave pos FB because the item was not damaged, so I said something like "item arrived quickly and described, but packed poorly." This might work in your situation.

I agree, you have to express sincerely if you were unsatisfied, even if it is just regarding packaging.

 

[Bella]

I had this same thing happen to me. A seller also crammed a bag into a priority box to small for the bag. I emailed the seller with my dissapointment. The response I got was rude and unprofessional. THAT is what pushed me to leave negative feedback for the seller. Had I received an apologetic response things probably would have been left at that. Of course I received a negative back, but I was okay with that and not surprised. For me it really comes down to the communication. If a buyer sees my negative and the replies to it, it is apparent who the problem was in the transaction.

So, I guess it's what feels best for you.