Went a little nuts this past week...

I dunno if its the lighting but in the (second to last) picture, the top item looks light pink compared to the other two. The bottom two are definitely rose pop...unless the top one is faded as another poster suggested.

Ahhhh, I LOVE your new items. LUCKY =))

The picture of the 3 together, the top one is definitely Framboise. It's the bottom 2 that are making me nuts. It's so hard to photograph the difference. The cosmetic case is BRIGHT pure pink. The middle one is like when you buy pink lipstick but it has very slight blue/purple undertones. There's almost an opalescence to it.
 
I have heard that vernis colours will slightly change colour with use which is especially noticeable with the light colours. But vernis colour can very slightly vary from piece to piece. So in your case it might be a combination of the two factors but I think they're both rose pop. Hths :smile:
 
A while back I revealed my Amarante cles that I got at the boutique. I ended up returning it but intermittently regretted it! So when this popped up preloved but looking brand new (and complete with its box, dust bag and cleaning cloth), I pounced on it!

As you can see in my signature, I dream of rose pop. I don't see it turn up often. I've got a cles that I THINK is rose pop... And just got my hands on a cosmetic bag!

It's gorgeous! Super bright pink. But...

...it's not the same as my cles. Here they are together.

It's only a small difference, but a difference nonetheless. Both are from 2009. Any idea which one is actually rose pop and which one isn't? What is the one that isn't? Or... is the color just varied from use? The cosmetic case is unused, the cles is worn. This pink business is confusing me!

I know neither are framboise. I have a small cles in that and it's very different from the two of these. I heard there's a fuchsia... Was that still around in 2009? Because the cosmetic bag definitely fits that color description.

One more comparison.

No, no... Two more! Framboise, rose pop, fuchsia?

...and I have a stole coming, too! Will reveal once its here.

OMG - Congrats :smile:. I LoVe LoVe LoVe Your Cosmetic Case You're so Lucky to have found this :smile:
 
I have heard that vernis colours will slightly change colour with use which is especially noticeable with the light colours. But vernis colour can very slightly vary from piece to piece. So in your case it might be a combination of the two factors but I think they're both rose pop. Hths :smile:

I'll take that explanation! Thank you :smile: