Wedding gift: Cartier love, rolex or hermes birkin (black)?

[ShoesNBagsGirl]

Birkin or Rolex!

 

[blumster]

I think the rolex is the best choice from in-laws- fun!

 

[cwool]

Rolex

 

[MyLuxuryDiary]

Rolex

 

[livebycoco]

Rolex

thank you all for the suggestions
i REALLY want a rolex too, but I have 3 watches already: ballon bleu mixed gold and silver and the tank and the chanel J12...so I don't know if I need another watch, especially given I don't even wear my existing ones? what do you think?

 

[lanasyogamama]

Awesome! I would go for either 1 or 2, whichever one you love more. Those two seem like "forever" gifts.

 

[lanasyogamama]

thank you all for the suggestions
i REALLY want a rolex too, but I have 3 watches already: ballon bleu mixed gold and silver and the tank and the chanel J12...so I don't know if I need another watch, especially given I don't even wear my existing ones? what do you think?

Oh, based on this I'd go with the Love.

 

[laurineg1]

Definitely the Love bracelet...your in-laws really do love you!

 

[SS57]

Oh, based on this I'd go with the Love.

I would go for the love bracelet! I really enjoy wearing mine.

 

[everything posh]

Since you have some really great watches already I would go for the Birkin!!!
The Love bracelet I feel should come from DH at some point.

 

[Pazdzernika]

Since you have some really great watches already I would go for the Birkin!!!
The Love bracelet I feel should come from DH at some point.

Yup, mine is meaningful because DH gifted it on a special anniversary.

 

[amrx87]

i think that the rolex would be most appropriate, considering that your hubby will be giving you a ring, and i see handbags as a more personal purchase.

that being said, can we trade in-laws?!

 

[skyqueen]

Birkin!
You don't seem like a watch person.
Your DH should get you the Love...maybe for a special occasion?

 

[fashionscoop]

The birkin since I think it is a classic bag that will last for many years.

 

[Bitten]

Congratulations on your upcoming wedding!!

I think a Rolex is most appropriate in this situation, as a Love would be more something your DH would get you perhaps as an anni gift, and a Birkin doesn't quite feel like a wedding present.

If I were in your situation, I would gently sound out your FIL and MIL as to whether they have a preference out of the three?