I think you should wait. As I recall, you like bling, and I think you will find the two MOP butterfly earrings boring.
Are you sure you can't love the pave and pink sapphire butterfly earrings? Those are such a perfect match!


On the all pave earrings, if you get those, I think the WG will pop more than the RG. Also, I see the ring you have as more WG due to the WG pave butterfly. If you did not like the WG pave, I'm not sure you will love the RG pave.
Maybe try the pave and pink sapphire butterfly earrings again, wear your ring, and stand in front of a full length mirror?
For me, matchy matchy is more important than getting each piece that looks great. There is nothing more beautiful than a matching set. I don't have to love every piece individually, but l love having a matched set above all else.
My Lotus set is the perfect example. I love the Lotus ring, but I do not love the Lotus earrings. I would never buy the earrings on their own as I find them a bit "common" and not really any special design. I looked at other earrings that might match my Lotus ring, but nothing made my heart sing for a match. I ended up purchasing the Lotus earrings, and I love love love the matching set.
I think if you want to buy something available now, my first choice would be the pave and pink sapphire to have a perfect set.
If not, pave and yellow sapphire, and then third is all WG pave. I think while the conventional thought "get diamonds!", to me, the butterfly earrings are far more creative and whimsical if the earrings are un-matched, like the ring.
If you are still not sure, I would wait and not force it. I still have nor ordered my oynx set yet because I can't decide on what pieces I want to make the set! The lack of inventory does not help either to try them on.


For me, if I spend too many brain cells trying to make a set, I take a break and move on to another set I want. Hence, I'm taking break from oynx and will get some other pieces next.... another big ring for sure!

So, maybe take a break. In the meantime, just wear something that works with your ring even though it's not quite what you want.
Here on TPF, we tend to be super picky about putting pieces together. In reality, 90% of the population just throws jewelry on and it works! I am sure whatever you wear with your ring will be lovely! You have a ton of beautiful pieces, and it will work!