I placed an order for the lapis ring (need a MTO size) (yay!) But I also love the turquoise and pink sapphire. Not as much of a yellow sapphire or tsavorite person. I haven’t been able to see the pink in person, it’s never been in stock. I also am not as big of a fan of the lapis or turquoise in earring form, not sure why.I just tried on all four butterfly rings: lapis/diamond, turquoise/diamond, pink sapphire/diamond, yellow sapphire/diamond.
For me, I decided I will not be buying a butterfly set as I felt the butterfly ring was a bit too small on me.
That said, no, both rings are not redundant if you are a butterfly ring lover.
To me, lapis remains the BOMB! I know this is the turquoise thread, but to me, there is no comparison. The lapis is so stunning, and that deep blue makes it a bold statement piece. It definitely pops, unlike the yellow sapphire and pink sapphire which I thought was a bit mellow. The turquoise butterfly is super fun! Think glowy turquoise for the summer. The turquoise pops too, but it's a fun pop.
If you love the butterfly ring, they are definitely not duplicates, and I would get both. The two shades each project a different look. Both are great rings. Good luck on your decision!
I have tried on turquoise and lapis rings. I think in an ideal world I would do Turquoise, lapis and pink sapphire rings, and pink sapphire/pave earrings. but that is a bit much.
I’m not worried about getting the pink sapphire in the future… I think that should always be there. Turquoise I am not sure. Maybe I will ask to try it again another time to see if I just cannot stop thinking about it. Ive attached these photos before to a different thread, so sorry for redundancy, but I think they both look nice (but lapis moreso!)
I am a little concerned about having turquoise from a durability standpoint too, especially on my hands. My SA said I should wait and get lapis first, then decide on turquoise.