Yep! I had to "Settle" on this one also. We spent more than we wanted to, but we also had to go with what was likely secondhand. Like someone traded it in at some point. Which is FINE BY ME.
...Though shrinkage is a horrible thing. lol
LOL .... oh the things we "settle" for. Just like I "settled" for my F color since they didn't have a G color for what I wanted... LOL
I also don't think i'd mind a traded in stone if it was amazing and what I wanted. At least you know you have the quality of the old cutters versus getting a new one that might not be as good. A lot of older designer products I prefer the older versions because the quality was so much better.
Shrinkage? already? Your e-ring substantially grew from original and the size does look amazing on you! But that's just me. Do you think the band width of the wedding band will really bother you?