I bought the smooth black small version ("clutch" with a long detachable strap) with GHW a few months ago. I love it! It's a surprisingly roomy bag, so it could definitely work for day-to-night if you aren't carrying a ton. The leather is gorgeous, and although it is smooth, it seems very scratch resistant so far. The clasp isn't as easy to close as a zipper, but I don't find it to be a problem, and if it doesn't close, the top still stays down. The top of mine doesn't slouch like the large version, but perhaps it will soften with time, and it looks good as is. Also since it's rounded, I find it very comfy to wear. I love this bag so much that I'm thinking about the large tan and small cream.