YOU make both of them look wonderful ! The dark blue one beautilly reflects the color of your eyes, but the vermillion one looks more young, more lively, more vibrant and gives a glow, as Fowytrini said. Keep both of them if you can...
Your summary is perfect, I was trying to define the difference with navy being more "formal" and highlighting Ms. Bunnycat's eyes and with the red one being more "casual" and matching lipstick colour. Both look great and may be useful depending on the occasion and mood
Thank you all so much for weighing in fellow scarfies!
I knew you would all understand the problem. So I have let fate decide. I decided to pack them both up, print off return labels and then when I got to the drop off place, I would pick one then. That's how hard this was to choose. Aaaaaaannnnnddddd.....
As I was packing the blue one back up and folding it, the tag fell off....so now the blue one is mine (for now). I do intend to reassess the situation if ever I find the pink one. When I called back about it, they were all sold out, so I never actually got to try the pink one. Perhaps that would have been the best compromise between colorful background, and pretty feathers...I may never know now. I do like the blue one. The both looked very nice, and it is true I am looking for a red cashmere (because I don't have one) but I think maybe I am looking for very very red, like cherry and not tomato red.
