I have an old medium boy and a medium gabrielle. Personally, I slightly prefer the gabrielle myself but this is simply because I can’t find much use for the boy considering my current collection. But that’s just me. I think they are very different, so it would be like comparing apples with oranges tbh. My best advice is to go try them on and see which you fall in love with.
A few things to consider:
- How do you plan to use this bag (for work, weekend, etc) and what else you already have in your collection? Which size are you considering? Neither is an all-occasion bag imo. For example, small/old medium boy not really practical for work and may or may not fit your daily essentials. Same with small gabby, and medium gabby isn’t elegant enough for evenings...
- Boy is structured and gabby is slouchy. Do you have any preference either way?
- The boy will scream Chanel at first glance while the gabrielle is under the radar? Any preference here?
- Seems like the boy may be here to stay whereas gabby’s future is still left to be seen. Do you mind about this?
- Some people don’t really like the chains on the gabby and some are worried that the base won’t stay pristine. On the other hand, some feel the boy very boxy and difficult to access.