Hi all,
I would really appreciate your opinion on this:
A black coat has been on my list and my mind for the past few years and I am finally ready to get it but I have no store near me to go and try Max Mara main line coats to compere them and I can't decide if I should get the black Manuela or the black Madame. I have already the Manuela in camel and love it, I also think the Madame looks great in camel (or the other light colours) but I am not sure I like it that much in black... I don't know if it makes sense to go for the same style different colour or would be better to have a Madame in my collection too (even tough I would like it more in a different colour)...
I am gravitating more towards Madame purely because IMHO it looks more casual and it would be more wearable as an everyday coat... but at the same time the Manuela could also be dressed up or down...

I would love to hear what you think.
Thank you so much in advance
Hi! My two cents…
I have tried both, and I have the Manuela, black and also red. I love the Manuela as it looks fabulous with any outfit.
The Madame is very very loose which is fine. However, the deal breaker for me was the kimono sleeves. The sleeves are very wide, but worse, there is no defined shoulder line. This means if you have small or round shoulders, your shoulders will look droopy. Also, again on the sleeves, there is a lot of space under the armpit. The cut is a very generous cut, so you have to really love that look.
I have square shoulders, but I am small, 5’ 2”, so I felt the coat wore me.
I even like big, loose fitting coats and buy my Max Maras one size up. This coat just did not look elegant on me.
I love the Manuela, and I do purchase repeats of styles I love, not just coats, but tops, pants, shoes, etc. Wearing coats to me is about what looks great on you, and different colors are very different coats. You can have a camel color coat and a black color coat, same style and it looks very different.
On the contrary, if you had a black Manuela and black Madame, I would say they look the same.
Max Mara coats last years. I say get the coat style that looks amazing on you.
For me, it’s the Manuela, and I hope it comes out in ivory next season. I would love to add an ivory to my black and red.
Just my two cents. Hope this helps you decide. Pay attention to the shoulder and armpit. How those two areas fit make or a break the look in a coat to me.