Agreed. I initially purchased Battery Park at Wall Street and wound up not keeping it. When I bought the Pierre Charpin this weekend, Madison had a Battery Park so I bought it again. Exactly the same.
I do think it is limited in that I do not believe it was offered for store ordering at podium. Not as wide of a production as most scarves, and not part of any definable “season”. It seems that after the original NYC printing more were added and the other US boutiques just got whatever they got.
Wow, an SA convinced me that the reissued design is just a tiny bit skewed or angled or zoomed in or something. I couldn’t compare so IDK.