Growing up I was a huge NIN fan. Hurt was on thier The Downward Spiral album around '94-'95. I was not pleased when I heard the Johnny Cash cover, but I quickly got over it and now love both.
Covering a song is a huge risk. Not to step on anyones toes but, I think Faith Hill butchered Janice Joplins Piece of my heart.
Some songs are so iconic that no one can recreate them and not sound like a fool.
That's how I feel about Staind when they play 'Sober' by Tool. Aaron Lewis butchered that song and when I hear it, it makes me so mad. But he changed some of the chords and and the lyrics because he didn't want to go through the legalities (I guess thats the right word) and not only that, but Maynard the lead singer of Tool won't allow it. All of Tool's songs have meanings behind them. Deep meanings and I too wouldn't want someone copying my songs.
admat97 - are you talking about Johnny Cash's video? If so, than I've cried watching it before too.