Share Your Recent Bag Offers Thread

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I would pass on a B30 sellier in favor of a B25 sellier. All of my 30Bs are retourne and they are large enough. I am a fan of sellier and of box, barenia, VN, hunter and swift. I don’t find them difficult to maintain (if you do a search, I have posted about this and the pros and cons in a variety of other threads). You might also want to check out this thread

@RainbowTweedy some great info from our lovely @880 here as always if you want to take a look! <3
 
I was offered a Birkin Sellier Box Calf black 35 ghw. I am truly not very familiar with the box calf leather.

Does anyone have photos of how they age? Are you glad you purchased? I tend to keep more to the more forgiving/durable leathers.

Is this an in demand bag? I am used to seeing epsom or togo.
I have this bag in a 30 and I love it, but it's a different look. It's stiff, has a slight shine, looks a little more dressy, will never have the slouch of other birkins. I like it as a complement to the others in my collection, and am so happy to have it, but it is not an everyday bag for me (though maybe it would be if I didn't have such a casual lifestyle and if I had to dress for work). I would NOT buy it in a 35, though... that would look like a stiff, giant box imo. I am a huge fan of box leather in general.
 
Thank you! I was checking the box calf page on here to get an idea of how the leather ages. It is just not a leather of theirs I have considered before. I tend to prefer the heartier ones. (I think I was mistaken and it is a 30 not 35.)
I have it and it’s my favorite bag. It’s super beautiful and very special. But I love structural bags.
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
I understand that it can be challenging to pick between the available Kelly sizes, especially since Box is a push offer. My suggestion would be to try out both sizes to determine which one will work best for you. You don't want to spend your hard-earned money on a bag that won't suit your needs or won't be able to use as much.
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
I have a kelly 28 in box, never took it out of the box it's just too big for me. I regret not going for the Kelly 25 in box instead but it all depends on your preference and what suits you. I just prefer smaller bags in general
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
The difference is not that much imo, having owned a retourne K25 and tried on sellier K28s. And box kelly being so rare and only push offered, l will make an exception just for this one with regards to size (up to 28, 32 is too big for my frame). Crossbody with 28 sellier is a bit ‘in the way’ though
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
Personally I feel that box leather has such a beautiful sheen that it makes it more of a formal purse. I like mine in the K25 size because I can use it in the evenings!
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
Go for the K25. I wear mine crossbody with a canvas strap.
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
I’d say box in k25 since you don’t have any and the size would be better to wear crossbody
 
Any votes on box Kelly in 25 or 28? I originally asked for a K25 in box leather and was asked if would be okay w K28 instead recently. I’m tempted to say yes since lusting after box and like K28 size. Just don’t have any K25s and tend to use more crossbody so K28 lays a little big that way. Any one w box K25/K28 w some advice? Thank you!
There is a thread re this issue with pics here:
my post #4 shows action pics with K25, 28, 32. I’m 5’2, size 38 chanel, size 36 Hermes, size 40 dior

if it makes a difference to you, I believe in the US and ASia, many wear a 25
in the US, a 25 is still harder to get as an offer

i see plenty of 28 and 32 in UK and Paris, and bigger bags are trending again
Also if your significant other wants you to carry his sunglasses for him, a 25 usually will be too small
 
Last edited:
Top