Share Your Edited Bag Closet Journey......

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

I like hearing about where people are with their bag collections. Pre-pandemic I downsized as I wasn’t using all my bags. A couple of months ago I was still at one Mulberry (used occasionally) and three Bottega Venetas (used rarely) and a Coach briefcase (used daily for work). I just transfer essentials to my pockets when not at work, or use a tote bag if I’m going to the farmer’s market or something. I think two things contributed to the lack of bag use: downsizing a couple of years ago to a pocket-size wallet (awesome) and getting a dog (also awesome but my fancy bag use declined). I am now bitten by the bag bug again and as long as I have adequate storage space, I’ve decided I’m OK adding to the collection simply to use these bags once in a while. With BV on its second designer after Tomas Maier, whose designs I really liked, I know these bags won’t be available forever.
 
I believe I have found the tipping point for me and it was about 3 bags ago..... LOL. I look forward to hearing more about your plan (or plan for a plan) as it progresses.

I am about to do a seasonal reorg that will expand my CFDB - it needs to hold a few bags while I reassess.

And I am always inspired by your wisdom and beautiful, creative approach to living!

Thank you for the kind words. Are you ready to share what you’ve decided to keep and what you’re thinking about letting go?
I need to narrow down my medium sized bags. I also need to thin out my clutches. I don’t have any numbers yet but I’m trying not to move too quickly, as I hope not to make decisions I later question. On the other hand, I think I’m used to having too many bags and that it’s distorted my ability to be objective. I’m sure that my “wants” exceed my “needs”. It seems like it should be an easy issue to remedy but that hasn’t been the case….:facepalm:
 
  • Like
Reactions: frenziedhandbag
Took the Neverfull to rebag (waiting for them to do their own authentication so I can sell) and bought the Longchamp Le Pliage, also bought and returned a Chanel mini with top handle (Lovely to look at but that's where that ended for me.) Also bought a coach nolita from the outlet shop which I'm hoping will replace the $17 mini bag I have. I feel like I'm always on the search for a mini bag that's functional, not very recognizable, light weight, can take a beating, can be worn both casually and to formal events... I thought the Chanel mini with top handle would be it, but nope.

Reason for selling the Neverfull PM : Crappy handles is the biggest one, it's a very open tote with no zip, not a bag that can take a beating like people would make you believe, also the Longchamp wins out in terms of portability, being light weight, having a zipper, being damn near water proof. Also, you can buy ten Longchamps for the price of a Neverfull now because that bag is still the same price as when I bought it 6 years ago.

I love the idea of a Longchamp but have never owned one. You make it sound like a great practical bag. I’m going on record that I can’t add one unless I let go of at least one bag currently in my life.
 
I like hearing about where people are with their bag collections. Pre-pandemic I downsized as I wasn’t using all my bags. A couple of months ago I was still at one Mulberry (used occasionally) and three Bottega Venetas (used rarely) and a Coach briefcase (used daily for work). I just transfer essentials to my pockets when not at work, or use a tote bag if I’m going to the farmer’s market or something. I think two things contributed to the lack of bag use: downsizing a couple of years ago to a pocket-size wallet (awesome) and getting a dog (also awesome but my fancy bag use declined). I am now bitten by the bag bug again and as long as I have adequate storage space, I’ve decided I’m OK adding to the collection simply to use these bags once in a while. With BV on its second designer after Tomas Maier, whose designs I really liked, I know these bags won’t be available forever.
I like hearing about others’ collections, too. I find it motivating. I sometimes wish I’d kept a few of my BV nodini‘s.….especially after seeing @grietje carrying hers on a girls trip in Carmel. I’ve added a couple of Aline’s & TPM’s in their place….
 
I love the idea of a Longchamp but have never owned one. You make it sound like a great practical bag. I’m going on record that I can’t add one unless I let go of at least one bag currently in my life.
I know I'm not helping but if you really want the Le Pliage you can just go for it. Add a whole new catagory and call it your contemporary throw around bag. If you fold it up, it takes up no space at all:giggle:

If I am a bit more serious I do mean what I say. You already know that I think of bags in feelings and not in numbers. There is a difference between the bags we want and the bags we need. A very reasonably priced all weatherproof trow around bag to lug in your belongings is not the same as a bag that costs in the four digits, something you buy because of the model, the colour, the leather, the fashionhouse or the history.

Maybe I am too biased because I don't love my LP. This is not a bag you need to love but love to use.
 
I know I'm not helping but if you really want the Le Pliage you can just go for it. Add a whole new catagory and call it your contemporary throw around bag. If you fold it up, it takes up no space at all:giggle:

If I am a bit more serious I do mean what I say. You already know that I think of bags in feelings and not in numbers. There is a difference between the bags we want and the bags we need. A very reasonably priced all weatherproof trow around bag to lug in your belongings is not the same as a bag that costs in the four digits, something you buy because of the model, the colour, the leather, the fashionhouse or the history.

Maybe I am too biased because I don't love my LP. This is not a bag you need to love but love to use.
+1 on LP but I am definitely attached to some of them emotionally (my weekend and carryon travel bags are all LP and are either personalized or packed with lovely travel memories). I've been through so many iterations of $$$ carryons from various designers over the years, but each one fell short in some important way and I realized a few years ago that nothing beats the expandable Longchamp travel bag. I tend to wait for the seasonal colors and also replace them when they start looking tatty. And yes they fold up into nothing!

@diane278 you have given me "food for thought" about sizing and priorities. I abandoned my bag usage tracking spreadsheet midway through 2021 because its very existence confirmed that I had too many bags (and the results were basically what I already knew about faves)..... but also I have rarely met a problem that couldn't be solved with a spreadsheet.

Oh, and my "no bags in 2022 unless I get myself to FSH" went out the window. I am at 4 so far (each one totally justified of course), plus an its-not-a-bag-its-an-SLG pouch that I'm using as a WOC. The shame is almost paralyzing. :graucho: Perhaps I need a new bag to make me feel better.
 
I know I'm not helping but if you really want the Le Pliage you can just go for it. Add a whole new catagory and call it your contemporary throw around bag. If you fold it up, it takes up no space at all:giggle:

If I am a bit more serious I do mean what I say. You already know that I think of bags in feelings and not in numbers. There is a difference between the bags we want and the bags we need. A very reasonably priced all weatherproof trow around bag to lug in your belongings is not the same as a bag that costs in the four digits, something you buy because of the model, the colour, the leather, the fashionhouse or the history.

Maybe I am too biased because I don't love my LP. This is not a bag you need to love but love to use.

In my bag history, which began in my 20’s, I have been a collector of Coach, LV, back to Coach, Bottega, and now Hermes. Each time, I dove into the brand with gusto but little common sense. Limiting my collection size is my personal way of trying to exert some common sense on my shopping. Although Hermes is certainly the most expensive of my collecting, and cost is a consideration, I would like to be more practical.

Previously, I eliminated many bags by giving them away. I also have a good friend who’s sold some for me. Then my faux granddaughter showed interest in BV. That was a godsend. We would go out to lunch and then I’d let her shop my bag closet. She still loves and uses the BV’s she has. She has not shown any real interest in my Hermes. Looking back, I easily made do with a collection of about ten bags at a time. I’d like to return to something in that area. Of course, when I was in my 20’s I was much more limited in what I could afford and that provided some much needed brakes in my purchasing.

I think I enjoy the journey as much as actually having the bags…..
 
+1 on LP but I am definitely attached to some of them emotionally (my weekend and carryon travel bags are all LP and are either personalized or packed with lovely travel memories). I've been through so many iterations of $$$ carryons from various designers over the years, but each one fell short in some important way and I realized a few years ago that nothing beats the expandable Longchamp travel bag. I tend to wait for the seasonal colors and also replace them when they start looking tatty. And yes they fold up into nothing!

@diane278 you have given me "food for thought" about sizing and priorities. I abandoned my bag usage tracking spreadsheet midway through 2021 because its very existence confirmed that I had too many bags (and the results were basically what I already knew about faves)..... but also I have rarely met a problem that couldn't be solved with a spreadsheet.

Oh, and my "no bags in 2022 unless I get myself to FSH" went out the window. I am at 4 so far (each one totally justified of course), plus an its-not-a-bag-its-an-SLG pouch that I'm using as a WOC. The shame is almost paralyzing. :graucho: Perhaps I need a new bag to make me feel better.

First if all, my new mathematical equation suggests a new bag might help you feel better! The pandemic did not help me set any limits. I don’t have a spreadsheet but here’s my basic bag math equation:
Time + Covid isolation + internet + rationalization = Bag Collection Growth
Am I missing any components in this equation? I’ve never been good at math so this may need some changes.
 
First if all, my new mathematical equation suggests a new bag might help you feel better! The pandemic did not help me set any limits. I don’t have a spreadsheet but here’s my basic bag math equation:
Time + Covid isolation + internet + rationalization = Bag Collection Growth
Am I missing any components in this equation? I’ve never been good at math so this may need some changes.
Rotfl! On the east coast we must also factor in Old Man Winter - 3 of my 4 recent purchases were majorly influenced by them being bright pop colors.
 
  • Like
Reactions: diane278
Are you ready to share what you’ve decided to keep and what you’re thinking about letting go?
(You may be sorry you asked!)

Last year I went a bit nuts with “Doodah” bags. Pandemic-related lifestyle changes, some of which are permanent, led me to rethink my collection focus, which turned out to be mostly a mistake. But any lessons learned are valuable!

I let go of a couple of H bags last year that were style dupes (no regrets), but the rest are staying. They all get carried at least once in a while, but even if they didn’t they are almost art objects and were either too much of a PITA to acquire, are essentially irreplaceable (discontinued colors/styles that I lucked into), or I am simply emotionally attached to them even though they spend 97% of their lives in my closet (Bolide Secret, my oddball crumpet). I will revisit these in a couple of years.

I branched out last year back into Fendi (mini fuchsia Peekaboo that will get lots of love this spring) and Ferragamo. The Fendi and one Ferragamo (a tote that I am loving a lot and is unlike anything else I have) are staying.

I am over being sad about what happened with Moynat and am staring down what I have left of Ramesh’s designs. Two are being rehomed because they don’t fit my lifestyle anymore but the rest (two daybags and one mini) get used and loved. Moving on.

Last year I commissioned a Dream Bag from Peter Nitz, which was a fantastic experience. It’s suede and going to move to the top shelf soon until the fall, but it’s a keeper and I plan to order another from him, probably this year, if not next.

A chance encounter last month with a lady carrying a chic and well-loved Ricky led me into the Ralph Lauren boutique where I impulse bought a 33 in a fantastic and versatile taupe suede (@diane278 it’s kinda your BV Barn Bag’s soul mate). It definitely fills a gap in my collection and will get a lot of use until summer.

Most of the doodahs are gone - Vanessa Bruno makes great cabas totes, but the ones I had didn’t just work with my organizer “system.” Her raffia bags are also great but I don’t do the beach and the material ruins a lot of clothing fabrics. An Italian tote from a quirky local boutique was too floppy. (All going.) A smallish and utterly unique hair calf convertible backpack is a great color and makes me smile, so it stays at least until my next seasonal reevaluation. A red RSVP Paris minibag stays. Two recent Akris mini AIs stay (and may be followed by a larger model). Several more “what was I thinking?” purchases have been or are in the process of being moved along to happier owners.

I am also reorganizing my coat closet to accommodate my three largest bags (which I carry infrequently for work and only in very specific situations). I keep my canvas and fabric totes there too, but those I don’t count those in my “number.” That move will allow everything else to fit on my bag shelves with enough room for one or two more, although I’m going to stick to a strict “one in one out” program going forward (she says with complete sincerity). I have decided that “too many bags” means spillover, rather than a number. (This also has the nice result of accommodating my apparent shift to smaller bags in general.) I keep everything in dustbags, so if I do get to the point where I can’t remember what something is (senility?) I may rethink that approach, but for now it feels like a good place to be.

As always I feel so fortunate to be informed and inspired by the parallel curatorial journeys of you and everyone here! We are all a truly lucky lot. :hugs:
 
(You may be sorry you asked!)

Last year I went a bit nuts with “Doodah” bags. Pandemic-related lifestyle changes, some of which are permanent, led me to rethink my collection focus, which turned out to be mostly a mistake. But any lessons learned are valuable!

I let go of a couple of H bags last year that were style dupes (no regrets), but the rest are staying. They all get carried at least once in a while, but even if they didn’t they are almost art objects and were either too much of a PITA to acquire, are essentially irreplaceable (discontinued colors/styles that I lucked into), or I am simply emotionally attached to them even though they spend 97% of their lives in my closet (Bolide Secret, my oddball crumpet). I will revisit these in a couple of years.

I branched out last year back into Fendi (mini fuchsia Peekaboo that will get lots of love this spring) and Ferragamo. The Fendi and one Ferragamo (a tote that I am loving a lot and is unlike anything else I have) are staying.

I am over being sad about what happened with Moynat and am staring down what I have left of Ramesh’s designs. Two are being rehomed because they don’t fit my lifestyle anymore but the rest (two daybags and one mini) get used and loved. Moving on.

Last year I commissioned a Dream Bag from Peter Nitz, which was a fantastic experience. It’s suede and going to move to the top shelf soon until the fall, but it’s a keeper and I plan to order another from him, probably this year, if not next.

A chance encounter last month with a lady carrying a chic and well-loved Ricky led me into the Ralph Lauren boutique where I impulse bought a 33 in a fantastic and versatile taupe suede (@diane278 it’s kinda your BV Barn Bag’s soul mate). It definitely fills a gap in my collection and will get a lot of use until summer.

Most of the doodahs are gone - Vanessa Bruno makes great cabas totes, but the ones I had didn’t just work with my organizer “system.” Her raffia bags are also great but I don’t do the beach and the material ruins a lot of clothing fabrics. An Italian tote from a quirky local boutique was too floppy. (All going.) A smallish and utterly unique hair calf convertible backpack is a great color and makes me smile, so it stays at least until my next seasonal reevaluation. A red RSVP Paris minibag stays. Two recent Akris mini AIs stay (and may be followed by a larger model). Several more “what was I thinking?” purchases have been or are in the process of being moved along to happier owners.

I am also reorganizing my coat closet to accommodate my three largest bags (which I carry infrequently for work and only in very specific situations). I keep my canvas and fabric totes there too, but those I don’t count those in my “number.” That move will allow everything else to fit on my bag shelves with enough room for one or two more, although I’m going to stick to a strict “one in one out” program going forward (she says with complete sincerity). I have decided that “too many bags” means spillover, rather than a number. (This also has the nice result of accommodating my apparent shift to smaller bags in general.) I keep everything in dustbags, so if I do get to the point where I can’t remember what something is (senility?) I may rethink that approach, but for now it feels like a good place to be.

As always I feel so fortunate to be informed and inspired by the parallel curatorial journeys of you and everyone here! We are all a truly lucky lot. :hugs:

Geez, girl! You‘ve been busy! No wonder you needed a spreadsheet! You do seem to have figured out your path….I’m envious (I‘m still flopping around undecided about almost everything.) I do miss my suede barn bag and have been looking for another bag in suede (but smaller than the BV). I don’t think it’ll be a H bag. Once again, I have too many clutches. I’m using my Aline’s & TPM’s for daily drivers. One lesson I‘ve learned about myself is that by keeping the bags mostly out of sight (In the trunk) I don’t think about them that often. I guess it’s “out of sight, out of mind”. My first goal is to figure out how many clutches I’ll need from now on. It’s not many. I think I have 6 and I’d like to start with letting go of Thinking about actually getting started has tired me out. I need to rest. Then I’m going to look up some of the bags you mentioned that I don’t know….
 
  • Like
Reactions: whateve
Here’s my current bag family grouped by daily use….or non-use:

My small bags: used whenever I need a bag in my retirement community. Many days, I use a jacket pocket. Usual contents: phone; face mask; keys; sunglasses.
Black Aline; Etain TPM; Gold TPM; Barenia Aline’s
DC6564D0-6335-4EAB-93F1-1199B219CD4F.jpeg

My very neglected clutches:
Grey & Barenia Pouch; black & rouge grenat Octogones; rouge h Medor 29; Craie & black BdC’s
3B5B6522-0DB1-46F0-8F55-3E6CA59E898B.jpeg

Medium to large shoulder bags:
BBVerrou; Bottega steele & cement cervo loop; black Sellier Evie 29; black BdC ”smaller” shoulder bag


E59EB1FC-80AE-4D82-9DEF-7762C453C837.jpeg

Birkin 30 Tote (AKA My Cowgirl B)
I love this bag but it feels big to me……and it’s not carried often.
12B038A2-7F81-406A-8E20-7D76BD0BFBB5.jpeg
I left off the quilted RL pouch on a strap as I’m not feeling any love for it at all….it’s going to a better place….
 
Here’s my current bag family grouped by daily use….or non-use:

My small bags: used whenever I need a bag in my retirement community. Many days, I use a jacket pocket. Usual contents: phone; face mask; keys; sunglasses.
Black Aline; Etain TPM; Gold TPM; Barenia Aline’s
View attachment 5356158

My very neglected clutches:
Grey & Barenia Pouch; black & rouge grenat Octogones; rouge h Medor 29; Craie & black BdC’s
View attachment 5356154

Medium to large shoulder bags:
BBVerrou; Bottega steele & cement cervo loop; black Sellier Evie 29; black BdC ”smaller” shoulder bag


View attachment 5356153

Birkin 30 Tote (AKA My Cowgirl B)
I love this bag but it feels big to me……and it’s not carried often.
View attachment 5356152
I left off the quilted RL pouch on a strap as I’m not feeling any love for it at all….it’s going to a better place….
Fantastic collection! (And I always get the warm fuzzies when you show that very special Birkin.) Also I noticed on an earlier photo post that it looked like you had 2 identical Alines - I forgot that you had that fabulous belt buckle on one of them - genius!

It doesn't look like your bags are "crunching" you for space and your trunk is brilliant. I have just started to wonder how I might add a storage piece in my foyer or living area that could also hold some bags...... Hmmm.....I need to focus on the title of this thread and my mantra "Fewer. Better. Things."
 
Top