Share your 2020 bag offers!

TPF may earn a commission from merchant affiliate
links, including eBay, Amazon, and others

Status
Not open for further replies.
#106
LovingTheOrange said:
B25 Rose Sakura phw. Still deciding... I really had my heart set on a picnic Kelly. I feel like it’s one offer of the other.
Click to expand...
I understand the dilemma. Has your SA given you reason to think there could be a picnic Kelly coming that he or she could reserve for you? I have heard that the picnic Kelly might not be a quota bag, but I think you should talk through this all with your SA and have him/her help you decide!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou
#109
momoc said:
Good luck! Is it swift? I would just keep my eyes on the prize and wait for that picnic Kelly unless this was also on my wishlist these are very different bags...I'm sure it is a beauty though!
Click to expand...
Yes, it's swift! RS has been on my wishlist for the past 3 years. I requested it too late and H stopped making RS bags by then.

Rhl2987 said:
I understand the dilemma. Has your SA given you reason to think there could be a picnic Kelly coming that he or she could reserve for you? I have heard that the picnic Kelly might not be a quota bag, but I think you should talk through this all with your SA and have him/her help you decide!
Click to expand...
DoggieBags said:
Tough choice! I’d love a rose Sakura B25. But if your SA is pretty sure she can get u a picnic Kelly, I’d wait for that.
Click to expand...
My SM told me that each SA would be allocated one picnic kelly. Now my SA is saying "that was the idea, but we didn't get any". She said the store hasn't received any....
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou, craielover and momoc
#110
LovingTheOrange said:
Yes, it's swift! RS has been on my wishlist for the past 3 years. I requested it too late and H stopped making RS bags by then.



My SM told me that each SA would be allocated one picnic kelly. Now my SA is saying "that was the idea, but we didn't get any". She said the store hasn't received any....
Click to expand...
I know it’s quite tricky with Kelly Picnic- I have been waiting the the one for a while and still nothing. Nobody knows when to expect it ( of even If!) so I would stick with the beautiful BRS - it’s such a candy!! :girlsigh::love:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou, ChanelCelineLaurentLover and LovingTheOrange
#111
Sofiko said:
I know it’s quite tricky with Kelly Picnic- I have been waiting the the one for a while and still nothing. Nobody knows when to expect it ( of even If!) so I would stick with the beautiful BRS - it’s such a candy!! :girlsigh::love:
Click to expand...
I think I'm more torn because I actually know for a fact that one picnic kelly has already arrived. My friend purchased it. He also spent around 5x the price of the bag while purchasing it, which is something I'm not willing to do. Other than this one exception, I don't really have a reason to believe that I'm being deceived.
 
  • Like
Reactions: westcoastgal and Sofiko
#112
LovingTheOrange said:
I think I'm more torn because I actually know for a fact that one picnic kelly has already arrived. My friend purchased it. He also spent around 5x the price of the bag while purchasing it, which is something I'm not willing to do. Other than this one exception, I don't really have a reason to believe that I'm being deceived.
Click to expand...
Oh, I see! I would honestly ask my SA and explain my torture. If you have a good relationship (and I think you do if she considered you for mini picnic!) then the chance that she can advice you correctly is high! Good luck with the decision- it’s definitely a difficult one:girlsigh:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou and LovingTheOrange
#113
Sofiko said:
Oh, I see! I would honestly ask my SA and explain my torture. If you have a good relationship (and I think you do if she considered you for mini picnic!) then the chance that she can advice you correctly is high! Good luck with the decision- it’s definitely a difficult one:girlsigh:
Click to expand...
She just keeps reiterating that "none have arrived". She also told me to get the RS cus she knows I've been waiting for years, so it seems like a waste to let it go for bag that "may never arrive" according to her.

Now I have to rethink my wishlist for 2020, argh!!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou and Sofiko
#114
LovingTheOrange said:
Yes, it's swift! RS has been on my wishlist for the past 3 years. I requested it too late and H stopped making RS bags by then.
Click to expand...

Ahh ok now that's a dilemma! Knowing that it's also on your wishlist for years I'd change my vote to go ahead and get the Sakura B25.

Your friend that got the picnic - does he have the same SA as you? I feel like given what you said (one picnic per SA) it means he must be with a different SA. Maybe it's possible for her to not know what else came or got sold by others...or, I can understand if your SA just doesn't want to come out bluntly and say "yes we got one but it has to go to someone else because they spend a lot more" if that's her style (mine does tell me when she wanted to get something for me but couldn't, but that's only because we both prefer to keep it very open and direct and checked with each other this style is fine).

I also do understand your SA's point of getting what is already here. Assuming you have a good relationship with your SA otherwise...maybe follow her advice and take the B25 is the best. Maybe the picnic will come too, who knows! Good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: insidemysoul, TankerToad, Nerja and 3 others
#115
:hbeat:
LovingTheOrange said:
She just keeps reiterating that "none have arrived". She also told me to get the RS cus she knows I've been waiting for years, so it seems like a waste to let it go for bag that "may never arrive" according to her.

Now I have to rethink my wishlist for 2020, argh!!!
Click to expand...
She is probably not sure herself then. You can’t be wrong with BRS and it’s rare! I absolutely love the color and it’s so cute in B25 :love: Maybe you need to see it in person and then understand- if it’s Love it’s Love! :hbeat:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Culoucou and LovingTheOrange
#116
LovingTheOrange said:
Yes, it's swift! RS has been on my wishlist for the past 3 years. I requested it too late and H stopped making RS bags by then.



My SM told me that each SA would be allocated one picnic kelly. Now my SA is saying "that was the idea, but we didn't get any". She said the store hasn't received any....
Click to expand...


Girl those picnics have arrived and are gone to the VIPs and therefore I would plan to get RS especially since there is no 1 bag per semester rule anymore. Also more picnics are coming... so just get this and continue to reiterate your want.
 
  • Like
Reactions: westcoastgal, disappeared, TankerToad and 6 others
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top